I heard that if you took a peice of the sun the size of a pinpoint

  • Thread starter Thread starter Qaiphyx
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Sun The sun
AI Thread Summary
A pinpoint-sized piece of the sun would not burn everything within a 90-mile radius, as the amount of hydrogen in such a small volume is insufficient to create a blast of that magnitude. While compressing and cooling hydrogen could increase its density, calculations show that even at high temperatures, the energy released would not match the claimed destructive potential. The sun's fusion process, particularly the proton-proton chain, occurs slowly, contributing to its long lifespan. The core temperature of the sun is around 15 million K, with a density significantly higher than water, but this does not translate to a small piece causing widespread devastation. Overall, the initial claim lacks scientific validity.
Qaiphyx
Messages
92
Reaction score
0
that it would burn everying in a 90 mile radius, or something like that, is this correct? Would this be the same as if the equivelant amount of hydrogen atoms fused all at once together?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
It doesn't sound right, where did you hear this?

You could have quite a bit of hydrogen in the size of a pin point if you compressed and cooled it, but I still don't think you would have enough to create a blast with a 90 mile radius on earth.
 
Qaiphyx said:
that it would burn everying in a 90 mile radius, or something like that, is this correct? Would this be the same as if the equivelant amount of hydrogen atoms fused all at once together?
That doesn't sound right.

One can do a simple calculation based on a hydrogen plasma with the density of water, about 1 g/cm3, which is a little less than the average density. Multiply the density by the volume of a pin point to get the mass, and figure some appropriate temperature.

The sun is based on the pp-chain, and p-p fusion is very slow, say compared to d-d fusion, and that's why the sun has been around for a long time.

Bear in mind that the core of the sun is on the order of 15 million K, and its density if about 150 times that of water. In contrast, the photosphere has a temperature of about 5800 K and a density on the order of 1E-7 of water (at room temp).
 
I believe this figure results if you assume that the pinpoint (I suppose the head of a pin was meant) will magically stay at 15 million K, even when radiating such an enormous amount of energy.
 
Hello everyone, I am currently working on a burnup calculation for a fuel assembly with repeated geometric structures using MCNP6. I have defined two materials (Material 1 and Material 2) which are actually the same material but located in different positions. However, after running the calculation with the BURN card, I am encountering an issue where all burnup information(power fraction(Initial input is 1,but output file is 0), burnup, mass, etc.) for Material 2 is zero, while Material 1...
Back
Top