I need your Advice

  • #1
Marwan_Ahmed
11
0

Please everybody,
I need your advice
I have a proof in physics
it's about Gravitotinal time dilation
& also i'm about to put a basics in a theory about velocity & motion based on the proof.


all what i need is an advice telling me where to puplish it safely that no one could take it himself...???!!
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
bcrowell
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Insights Author
Gold Member
6,723
426
all what i need is an advice telling me where to puplish it safely that no one could take it himself...???!!

Submit it to a refereed journal. If you really think it's such a great discovery that an unscrupulous referee might try to steal it, you're protected, because the editor of the journal will keep a record of the date of the submission, and the date when it went out to the referee.
 
  • #3
Marwan_Ahmed
11
0
Submit it to a refereed journal.

like what, really i don't know
 
  • #4
starthaus
1,568
0
like what, really i don't know

Depends on what you have, can you show us a sample, like the abstract and the first chapter of your paper?
 
  • #5
Dale
Mentor
Insights Author
2021 Award
33,282
10,671
Most journals will have a mission statement or something similar on their website that will help you decide if your manuscript is appropriate. Another "rule of thumb" for determining the correct journal would be the journal from which most of your references came.
 
  • #6
Fredrik
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
10,875
420

Please everybody,
I need your advice
I have a proof in physics
it's about Gravitotinal time dilation
& also i'm about to put a basics in a theory about velocity & motion based on the proof.


all what i need is an advice telling me where to puplish it safely that no one could take it himself...???!!

Is this an attempt to prove relativity wrong? If so, you could ask questions here, and we could help you find out what you have misunderstood. Make sure you follow the forum rules. We're not really interested in personal theories and speculation here, but we might be able to help you understand relativity. If it's just a nice derivation of a well-known result, then maybe one of the "educational" journals is appropriate. For example, the European journal of physics.
 
  • #7
Marwan_Ahmed
11
0
Is this an attempt to prove relativity wrong? If so, you could ask questions here, and we could help you find out what you have misunderstood. Make sure you follow the forum rules. We're not really interested in personal theories and speculation here, but we might be able to help you understand relativity. If it's just a nice derivation of a well-known result, then maybe one of the "educational" journals is appropriate. For example, the European journal of physics.

No no relativity is 100% true
i'm sure of that
all what i'm trying to reach is proving gravitotinal time dilation with another way which based on it i could reach a new idea Motion & velocity fields on the Earth
 
  • #8
Altabeh
660
0
No no relativity is 100% true
i'm sure of that
all what i'm trying to reach is proving gravitotinal time dilation with another way which based on it i could reach a new idea Motion & velocity fields on the Earth

In this case you can try "http://prd.aps.org/" [Broken]" which is a prominent journal in elementary particle physics, field theory, gravitation and etc.

AB
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #9
Marwan_Ahmed
11
0
In this case you can try "http://prd.aps.org/" [Broken]" which is a prominent journal in elementary particle physics, field theory, gravitation and etc.

AB

I did what you told me bro
I registered but i don't know what to do next sorry
I'm new on the web world
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #10
Marwan_Ahmed
11
0
My prove & the theory of motion

well this is the prove I worked on along last 6 months
some says it's true other says it has a missing part ,
well this is their opinion & I will never give up

http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?pid=425413&id=1648127699 [Broken]
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #11
Dale
Mentor
Insights Author
2021 Award
33,282
10,671


Don't repeat posts like that. It is annoying.
 
  • #12
Frame Dragger
1,504
1


Marwan, I think you are struggling to communicate your thoughts in English. I understand a little, but mostly... ana laa afham. (forgive me if your native language is not Arabic).

May I suggest you use a combination of your own ability with English, and an online translator to help? Physics can be difficult enough without such a barrier.

Em.. "Ma'a Salama"
 
  • #13
starthaus
1,568
0


well this is the prove I worked on along last 6 months
some says it's true other says it has a missing part ,
well this is their opinion & I will never give up

http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?pid=425413&id=1648127699 [Broken]

I think you should give up, what you wrote is not only incorrect, it is not even wrong as W.Pauli would say. There is nothing but a collection of childish mistakes.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #14
starthaus
1,568
0
well this is the prove I worked on along last 6 months
some says it's true other says it has a missing part ,
well this is their opinion & I will never give up

http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?pid=425413&id=1648127699 [Broken]

This is unpublishable, it is just a collection of mistakes.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #15
Frame Dragger
1,504
1
This is unpublishable, it is just a collection of mistakes.

Not a shock... is there anything to work with in terms of teaching what those mistakes are, and where he went awry? I get a feeling the language barrier here is significant, but that's no reason to not attempt to teach.
 
  • #16
starthaus
1,568
0
Not a shock... is there anything to work with in terms of teaching what those mistakes are, and where he went awry? I get a feeling the language barrier here is significant, but that's no reason to not attempt to teach.

Has nothing to do with any "language barrier", look at his equations. You will need a facebook account.
 
  • #17
Frame Dragger
1,504
1
Has nothing to do with any "language barrier", look at his equations. You will need a facebook account.

I would sooner bob for apples in a dead cow's kidney's than go on Facebook. No offense :rofl:

I'll take your word for it starthaus, all kidding aside.
 
  • #18
starthaus
1,568
0
I would sooner bob for apples in a dead cow's kidney's than go on Facebook. No offense :rofl:

I'll take your word for it starthaus, all kidding aside.

I stopped reading after the : v_2^2=v_1^2+2g*h
 
Last edited:
  • #19
Marwan_Ahmed
11
0


Don't repeat posts like that. It is annoying.

please sir if it's so bad you have your opinion to say but don't hurt other people feelings

I'm only 18 and this is good that i'm thinking in such a thing
 
  • #20
Marwan_Ahmed
11
0
This is unpublishable, it is just a collection of mistakes.

please sir if it's so bad you have your opinion to say but don't hurt other people feelings

I'm only 18 and this is good that i'm thinking in such a thing
 
  • #21
starthaus
1,568
0
please sir if it's so bad you have your opinion to say but don't hurt other people feelings

I'm only 18 and this is good that i'm thinking in such a thing

It would be even better if you started studying physics. What you wrote is not physics.
 
  • #22
Frame Dragger
1,504
1
I stopped reading after the : v_2^2=v_1^2+2g*h_2

...And I don't blame you! Holy moley.

@Marwan_Ahmed: I'm sorry that your feelings have been hurt, but isn't it good to know that while you are thinking about these matters, your thinking on them is far off the mark? You have a chance to correct those errors and focus on learning, rather than creating a novel proof. Leave the... breakthroughs for later. For now, it can be best to focus on learning or you can end up confusing yourself terribly.
 
  • #23
Marwan_Ahmed
11
0
of course sir i want to learn physics
but my dad & mom insisted on learning medicine instead


then please the first three papers means nothing to me

please check the last four papers
please give me a chance

the first three papers i was sure 90% that they are wrong
but the last four papers really they are good & better than the first three ones
 
  • #24
Marwan_Ahmed
11
0


please check last four papers
please they are better than the first 3 ones
which i was sure that they are wrong
but needed your confirmation

Give me a last chance & see the last 4 papers
 
  • #25
berkeman
Mentor
63,246
14,204


Don't repeat posts like that. It is annoying.

Two threads merged. Please do not multiple post, Marwan.
 
  • #26
starthaus
1,568
0


please check last four papers
please they are better than the first 3 ones
which i was sure that they are wrong
but needed your confirmation

Give me a last chance & see the last 4 papers

The last 4 pages are as bad as the first 3.
 
  • #27
Frame Dragger
1,504
1
of course sir i want to learn physics
but my dad & mom insisted on learning medicine instead


then please the first three papers means nothing to me

please check the last four papers
please give me a chance

the first three papers i was sure 90% that they are wrong
but the last four papers really they are good & better than the first three ones

You know, biology, chemistry (which underly medicine) are all ultimately physics. You can easily study medicine and physics, but just as you would not perform surgery to learn how it works, you have to study the physics before you construct your own proofs.

This website, is an AMAZING resource of educational material. This is just a suggestion, because although this is against the grain for me, usually, I get the sense that you really want to learn, and believe this is the best way.

Instead of offering your work to be critiqued (or dismissed... and I'm sorry to say it truly is not coherent), why not learn here, what you need to know to go back and start fresh? As you said, you're 18, a young man in the prime of life. There is no need to be impatient. Take some time to learn...

If I were you, I'd let ask Starthaus, "Ok, I'm wrong [this] is what I'm trying to describe [laws of motion, etc]... what is the correct standard formulation of this? Is there one?" etc...
It is best to ask questions first, to learn. Think, by all means, and write whatever you want, but rushing physics... it just doesn't work.
 

Suggested for: I need your Advice

Replies
1
Views
304
Replies
33
Views
971
  • Last Post
Replies
27
Views
941
  • Last Post
Replies
22
Views
729
Replies
5
Views
898
  • Last Post
Replies
7
Views
637
Replies
3
Views
581
Replies
9
Views
624
Replies
4
Views
409
  • Last Post
Replies
15
Views
1K
Top