Is My Boat Acceleration Homework Solution Correct?

  • Thread starter Thread starter dark4santa
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Acceleration Boat
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving a physics homework problem involving a rowboat's acceleration, final velocity, and time to cross a stream. The calculations indicate that the boat's acceleration is approximately 0.56 m/s², leading to a final velocity of about 6.16 m/s after 11 seconds. For the remaining distance of 168 meters to the opposite shore, the time required is calculated to be around 27.27 seconds. There is a disagreement between the student's answers and the teacher's, particularly regarding the acceleration and final velocity values. The conversation highlights the importance of showing work in calculations and adhering to significant figures in scientific answers.
dark4santa
Messages
1
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



16. ) A row boat, starting from rest takes 11 seconds to travel 34 meters. If the boat maintains a uniform acceleration, what will be its instantaneous velocity at the end of the 11-second period??
17.) At the point in the stream where the boat is crossing, the stream is 202 meters wide. If the boat in Question 16 maintains its final velocity for the remainder of the trip, how much time will it need to reach the opposite Shore?
18.) What acceleration did the row boat initially experience in Question 16??

So this is a Question of my Teacher
Wherein i want to prove that I made the right answer. Can you please solve this ?? Because I am having difficulty in proving something without concrete evidence from other Physics geeks... I know this is a really easy problem but I need a more concrete proof. I have already done this but I am trying to make sure. My Teacher tried doing the constant velocity where in the equation is v=d/t

Homework Equations


d= vit + at^2/2
d= vt

The Attempt at a Solution


no.18)
d=vit+at^2/2
so since vi = 0 so i can remove vit
d=at^2/2
a=2d/t^2
a=2(34)/11^2
a= 68/121
a= 0.56m/s^2

no 16)
vf = vit + at
wherein vi = 0 so i can remove the vit in the equation
vf= at
vf= (0.56)(11)
vf= 6.16m/s or if i use the not rounded off part of .56m/s^2 6.18m/s

no 17)
d= 168
v= 6.16m/s
since the part wanted was the distance from the boat to the other shore which will be 202-34= 168
t=d/v
t= 168m/6.16m/s
t= 27.27s
or
t=168m/6.18/s
t= 27.18s

my Attempt
no. 16 . ) 6.16m/s
no. 17 . ) 27.27secs
no. 18 . ) a= .56m/s^2

My teacher's attempt
no. 16 . ) 3.09m/s
no. 17 . ) 56.38secs
no. 18 . ) 0.02m/s^2

I know my teacher is wrong already just looking at the Acceleration. I understand her because of the stress being put upon her though

I know the Significant Figures is wrong the reason for that is because my teacher wanted to have a 2 decimal at the end. I tried to argue with her but she's the teacher and she's a stubborn one.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
dark4santa said:

The Attempt at a Solution



my Attempt
no. 16 . ) 6.16m/s ✗[/size] 6.182 m/sec[/color]
no. 17 . ) 27.27secs ✗[/size] 27.18 sec[/color]
no. 18 . ) a= .56m/s^2

My teacher's attempt
no. 16 . ) 3.09m/s
no. 17 . ) 56.38secs
no. 18 . ) 0.02m/s^2
You have to watch those significant figures. :smile:

The data showed only 2 sig figs, so strictly speaking you should give answers only to 2 sig figs. But if you round acceleration to 2 sig figs, you can't then give time to 4 sig figs and expect that extra precision to make sense.
 
Last edited:
Your answers more or less look correct, but you do not show how you arrived at the solution. Please show your work and we can check on the correctness of your attempt..
 
dark4santa said:

Homework Statement



16. ) A row boat, starting from rest takes 11 seconds to travel 34 meters. If the boat maintains a uniform acceleration, what will be its instantaneous velocity at the end of the 11-second period??
17.) At the point in the stream where the boat is crossing, the stream is 202 meters wide. If the boat in Question 16 maintains its final velocity for the remainder of the trip, how much time will it need to reach the opposite Shore?
18.) What acceleration did the row boat initially experience in Question 16??

So this is a Question of my Teacher
Wherein i want to prove that I made the right answer. Can you please solve this ?? Because I am having difficulty in proving something without concrete evidence from other Physics geeks... I know this is a really easy problem but I need a more concrete proof. I have already done this but I am trying to make sure. My Teacher tried doing the constant velocity where in the equation is v=d/t


Homework Equations


d= vit + at^2/2
d= vt



The Attempt at a Solution


no.18)
d=vit+at^2/2
so since vi = 0 so i can remove vit
d=at^2/2
a=2d/t^2
a=2(34)/11^2
a= 68/121
a= 0.56m/s^2
yes
no 16)
vf = vit + at
wherein vi = 0 so i can remove the vit in the equation
vf= at
vf= (0.56)(11)
vf= 6.16m/s or if i use the not rounded off part of .56m/s^2 6.18m/s
yes but it should round off to 6.2 but if teacher wants it to 2 decimal places then use the 6.18
no 17)
d= 168
v= 6.16m/s
since the part wanted was the distance from the boat to the other shore which will be 202-34= 168
t=d/v
t= 168m/6.16m/s
t= 27.27s
or
t=168m/6.18/s
t= 27.18s
yeah...you need a nice stop watch to check your result to the nearest one-one hundreth of a second...say OK

I know my teacher is wrong already just looking at the Acceleration. I understand her because of the stress being put upon her though
I am sure she appreciates your understanding...I do...I've been wrong more than once...
Did you know you can start with Q.16 and use d = [(vi + vf)/2]t to solve for vf? It seems to be the forgotten one of the kinematic equations for constant acceleration...:cry:
 
I multiplied the values first without the error limit. Got 19.38. rounded it off to 2 significant figures since the given data has 2 significant figures. So = 19. For error I used the above formula. It comes out about 1.48. Now my question is. Should I write the answer as 19±1.5 (rounding 1.48 to 2 significant figures) OR should I write it as 19±1. So in short, should the error have same number of significant figures as the mean value or should it have the same number of decimal places as...
Thread 'A cylinder connected to a hanging mass'
Let's declare that for the cylinder, mass = M = 10 kg Radius = R = 4 m For the wall and the floor, Friction coeff = ##\mu## = 0.5 For the hanging mass, mass = m = 11 kg First, we divide the force according to their respective plane (x and y thing, correct me if I'm wrong) and according to which, cylinder or the hanging mass, they're working on. Force on the hanging mass $$mg - T = ma$$ Force(Cylinder) on y $$N_f + f_w - Mg = 0$$ Force(Cylinder) on x $$T + f_f - N_w = Ma$$ There's also...
Back
Top