Is the Mathematical Solution in the Book Incorrect or Am I Mistaken?

AI Thread Summary
The user is attempting to simplify the equation G1 = G1(1+F1) / (1 + G1F2(1+F1) into terms of G1, G2, H2, and H3, using definitions for F1 and F2. They derived a specific result but found a discrepancy with the book's solution, which includes an additional +1 in the denominator. After multiple attempts, the user consistently arrived at the same result as their initial calculation. Another participant confirmed the user's result using a computer algebra system, suggesting that the book may contain an error. The discussion centers around verifying the correctness of the mathematical solution presented in the book.
magnifik
Messages
350
Reaction score
0
I am trying to simply G1 = G1(1+F1) / (1 + G1F2(1+F1)) in terms of G1, G2, H2, and H3 where F1 = G2/(1-G2H2) and F2 = G3 / (1-G3H3)

i got the result
(G1(1-G2H2)(1-G3H3) + G1G2(1-G3H3)) / ((1-G2H2)(1-G3H3) + G1G3(1-G2H2) + G1G2G3)

however, the book gives the result with a +1 in the denominator so their denominator is 1 + (1-G2H2)(1-G3H3) + G1G3(1-G2H2) + G1G2G3

i did the problem 3 times and got the same answer. is the solution in the book a typo, or am i doing something wrong?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
magnifik said:
I am trying to simply G1 = G1(1+F1) / (1 + G1F2(1+F1)) in terms of G1, G2, H2, and H3 where F1 = G2/(1-G2H2) and F2 = G3 / (1-G3H3)

i got the result
(G1(1-G2H2)(1-G3H3) + G1G2(1-G3H3)) / ((1-G2H2)(1-G3H3) + G1G3(1-G2H2) + G1G2G3)

however, the book gives the result with a +1 in the denominator so their denominator is 1 + (1-G2H2)(1-G3H3) + G1G3(1-G2H2) + G1G2G3

i did the problem 3 times and got the same answer. is the solution in the book a typo, or am i doing something wrong?

I used Maple (a computer algebra system) to do the question and got your answer exactly. Either the book is wrong or you copied something incorrectly.

RGV
 
I picked up this problem from the Schaum's series book titled "College Mathematics" by Ayres/Schmidt. It is a solved problem in the book. But what surprised me was that the solution to this problem was given in one line without any explanation. I could, therefore, not understand how the given one-line solution was reached. The one-line solution in the book says: The equation is ##x \cos{\omega} +y \sin{\omega} - 5 = 0##, ##\omega## being the parameter. From my side, the only thing I could...
Back
Top