Is this Gas Expansion Problem a Quasi-Static Adiabatic Process?

  • #1
Terry Bing
48
6
MODERATOR'S NOTE: Moved from other forum, so no template

@Chestermiller
I am still having trouble figuring out if a given process is Quasi-static or not.
Consider the following case. The cylinder consists of an ideal gas at the bottom and a liquid of density ρ at the top separated by a piston of mass m and area A. Atmospheric pressure is p0. Again, piston and cylinder are insulating. Initially, the piston is at equilibrium. A heater is turned on in the gas. The gas will expand causing the liquid to spill out. Is this process a quasi-static adiabatic process? In this case there are no sudden changes.
upload_2018-2-22_12-27-6.png

If so then the final temperature T2(when piston reaches the top) should satisfy
T2V2γ-1=T1V1γ-1.
For a monatomic gas, we have γ=5/2, which gives us T2=(0.5)3/2T1, [Since V2=2V1]
Is this correct?
 

Attachments

  • upload_2018-2-22_12-26-50.png
    upload_2018-2-22_12-26-50.png
    941 bytes · Views: 425
  • upload_2018-2-22_12-27-6.png
    upload_2018-2-22_12-27-6.png
    949 bytes · Views: 786
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Terry Bing said:
MODERATOR'S NOTE: Moved from other forum, so no template

@Chestermiller
I am still having trouble figuring out if a given process is Quasi-static or not.
Consider the following case. The cylinder consists of an ideal gas at the bottom and a liquid of density ρ at the top separated by a piston of mass m and area A. Atmospheric pressure is p0. Again, piston and cylinder are insulating. Initially, the piston is at equilibrium. A heater is turned on in the gas. The gas will expand causing the liquid to spill out. Is this process a quasi-static adiabatic process?
It is not adiabatic because heat is being added to the gas. If the heat is added gradually enough, the process is quasi static.
In this case there are no sudden changes.
View attachment 220845
If so then the final temperature T2(when piston reaches the top) should satisfy
T2V2γ-1=T1V1γ-1.
No. As I said, the expansion is not adiabatic, and this equation applies to an adiabatic reversible process.
For a monatomic gas, we have γ=5/2,
No. For a monatomic gas, ##\gamma = 5/3##
Is this correct?
No.

In this problem, you need to start out by determining the pressure as a function of the change in piston elevation x (so that the work can be determined and the final temperature can be determined). What is the pressure on the gas initially? What is the pressure on the gas after the piston has risen by a distance x? What is the pressure on the gas when the piston has risen a distance h?
 
  • #3
Chestermiller said:
In this problem, you need to start out by determining the pressure as a function of the change in piston elevation x (so that the work can be determined and the final temperature can be determined). What is the pressure on the gas initially? What is the pressure on the gas after the piston has risen by a distance x? What is the pressure on the gas when the piston has risen a distance h?
Thanks, I understand. I got half the answer. A number of hasty mistakes on my part in the attempt above. The process isn't adiabatic. It isn't given whether the gas is mono or diatomic, so we don't know γ.
At any instant of time, external pressure on the gas is Pext=P0+ρgy+mg/A, where y is the depth of the water layer. Work done by the gas
[tex] W=\int_{0}^{h} P_{ext} A dy= \int_{0}^{h} (P_0 A+\rho g y A+mg) dy=P_0 A h+\frac{1}{2} \rho g h^2 A+m g h [/tex]
Now If we know the heat supplied,
[tex] Q-W=\Delta U [/tex]
But Q is not given in the question. Also, we don't know γ to get ΔU in terms of T.
 
Last edited:
  • #4
I got it. We can use equation of state for an ideal gas. Assuming the process is quasi-static, both initial and final states will be equilibrium states. Then
[tex] P_1 V_1 / T_1=P_2 V_2/ T_2 \\
\implies T_2=( \frac{V_2}{V_1}) (\frac{P_2}{P_1}) T_1 \\
\implies T_2=2(\frac{p_0 A+m g}{p_0 A+\rho g h A+m g}) T_1[/tex]
 
  • #5
Terry Bing said:
I got it. We can use equation of state for an ideal gas. Assuming the process is quasi-static, both initial and final states will be equilibrium states. Then
[tex] P_1 V_1 / T_1=P_2 V_2/ T_2 \\
\implies T_2=( \frac{V_2}{V_1}) (\frac{P_2}{P_1}) T_1 \\
\implies T_2=2(\frac{p_0 A+m g}{p_0 A+\rho g h A+m g}) T_1[/tex]
Very Good. It's just ##\Delta U=\frac{C_v}{R}\Delta (PV)##
 
Back
Top