Is This the Correct Thermodynamic Analysis of a Refrigerator Cycle?

[roam]

Homework Statement

http://img21.imageshack.us/img21/1197/questionof.jpg

The Attempt at a Solution

For the first part, if we assume that the cycle is reversible from the 2nd law we have

\Delta S = \frac{\Delta Q}{T}+S_{gen} = 0

And here is the Clasius Inequality

S_{gen} \geq 0 \implies \frac{\Delta Q}{T} \leq 0

\frac{Q_x}{T_1}-\int^{T_2}_{T_1} \frac{\Delta Q}{T} \leq 0

Since ΔQ = dT

\frac{Q_x}{T_1}-\int^{T_2}_{T_1} \frac{dT}{T} = \frac{Q_x}{T_1}- \ln \frac{T_2}{T_1} \leq 0

T_2 \geq T_1e^{\frac{Q_x}{T_x}}

Since we do not know the temprature values we can't make numerical calculation of the lower limit for the final temperature of y. But did I derive the correct equation?

For the second part of the equation, to find the minimum value of work that needs to be supplied to the heat pump I tried to use the 1st Law;

Q − W = U = 0 → W = mcΔT - U

How can we use this to show the above expression for W_min?

 

[roam]

We do not know if the cycle is reversible or irreversible. But I assumed that it is reversible because if it is not then more and more work is required due to the entropy generated.

 

[roam]

Okay, I figured out part (1) , but I'm still having some trouble working out the minimum work.

The entropy change of x is

\Delta S_x = \int^{T_2}_{T_1} C_p \frac{dT}{T} = C_p \ln \frac{T_2}{T_1}

The entropy change of y is

\Delta S_y = \int^{T_2’}_{T_1} C_p \frac{dT}{T} = C_p \ln \frac{T_2’}{T_1}

The total entropy change is

\Delta S_{tot} =\Delta S_x + \Delta S_y = C_p \ln \frac{T_2}{T_1} + C_p \ln \frac{T_2’}{T_1}

And we know from the entropy principal that ΔS ≥ 0, so

\left( C_p \ln \frac{T_2}{T_1} + C_p \ln \frac{T_2’}{T_1} \right) \geq 0

C_p \ln \frac{T_2T_2’}{T_1^2} \geq 0

The minimum value of T₂’ would be

C_p \ln \frac{T_2T_2’}{T_1^2} = 0 = \ln 1

\therefore T_2’ = \frac{T_1^2}{T_2}

Okay now the minimum work:

Heat removed from x to cool it is Q=C_p (T₁-T₂) and the heat added to y is Q+W=C_p (T₂'-T₁) so

W= C_p(T₂'-T₁)-C_p(T₁-T₂)=C_p(T'₂+T₂-2T₁)

Substituting the minimum temprature we found we end up with

W_{min} = C_p \left( \frac{T_1^2}{T_2} +T_2-2T_1 \right) = C_p \frac{(T_1-T_2)^2}{T_2}

But the expression I need is:

W_{min} = \frac{mc (T_1-T_2)^2}{T_2}

What could we do to arrive at that expression?

 

[roam]

The only way I can have:

W_{min} = C_p \frac{(T_1-T_2)^2}{T_2} = \frac{mc (T_1-T_2)^2}{T_2}

is if C_p is equal to mc. But how could this be?