I've been stuck on this problem forever.

  • Thread starter Thread starter mathrocks
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Stuck
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the electric field due to a uniformly charged slab using Gauss's law. The slab has a thickness of 2d and a uniform positive charge density, with the electric field derived as E = rho*d/(2ε) in the x direction for points x ≥ d. Participants clarify that the correct thickness of the slab is crucial, as an error in this value affects the final answer. One user mentions using masteringphysics.com for their calculations, indicating a potential discrepancy in the answer provided by the platform. The conversation emphasizes the importance of understanding the geometry and symmetry involved in applying Gauss's law correctly.
mathrocks
Messages
105
Reaction score
0
A Uniformly Charged Slab. A slab of insulating material has thickness 2d and is oriented so that its faces are parallel to the yz-plane and given by the planes x=d and x= - d. The y- and z-dimensions of the slab are very large compared to d and may be treated as essentially infinite. The slab has a uniform positive charge density rho.

Using Gauss's law, find the magnitude of the electric field due to the slab at the points x>=d.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
It's not tough once you've thought about it for a few years. Here is the answer.

Take a can (like one used for canned peaches) and send it through the plane of charge so that the bottom and top of the can are parallel to the plane of charge.

Now the electric flux through the can is (by gauss's law) the Integral[Dot[E,da]] where E is the electric field and da is the differential surface area is equal to 2*Pi*r^2 *E which is also equal to Q/e that is the enclosed charge divided by epsilon. But remember Q=2*pi*r^2 * d *rho.

The rest of the algebra is trivial

E=rho*d/(2e) facing in the x direction

PS. Use a symmetry argument to convince yourself that E is uniform along the top and bottom of the can and E is perpindicular to the top and bottom of the can
 
Last edited:
1st step is to draw a gaussian surface
2nd step is to find the flux = EA = E 2(pi)(r^2)
3rd step is to find the charge from the equation, rho = Q/V ; Q = rho * Volume =
(rho)[(2)(pi)(r^2)(d)]
4th step is to use gauss law, EA = Q/8.85X10^-12 and solve for E.

Epsilon = 8.85X10^-12
 
sinyud said:
It's not tough once you've thought about it for a few years. Here is the answer.

Take a can (like one used for canned peaches) and send it through the plane of charge so that the bottom and top of the can are parallel to the plane of charge.

Now the electric flux through the can is (by gauss's law) the Integral[Dot[E,da]] where E is the electric field and da is the differential surface area is equal to 2*Pi*r^2 *E which is also equal to Q/e that is the enclosed charge divided by epsilon. But remember Q=2*pi*r^2 * d *rho.

The rest of the algebra is trivial

E=rho*d/(2e) facing in the x direction

PS. Use a symmetry argument to convince yourself that E is uniform along the top and bottom of the can and E is perpindicular to the top and bottom of the can


I tried that answer and the website that I'm using to enter in answers says that the answers you gave is off by a multiplicative factor.
 
answer

exactly, my answer is the correct one.
 
My bad,

The thickness of your charge is 2*d not just d . This should work.

E=rho*d/e facing in the x direction

BTW; what website are you using? Webassign?
 
sinyud said:
My bad,

The thickness of your charge is 2*d not just d . This should work.

E=rho*d/e facing in the x direction

BTW; what website are you using? Webassign?

No, it's masteringphysics.com, made for the book I am using.
 
Back
Top