Justifying the purchase of a plastic box over plastic bags.

  • Thread starter Thread starter smalveh
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Box Plastic
AI Thread Summary
To justify the purchase of a polypropylene lunchbox over disposable polyethylene bags, the energy life cycle of both products must be considered. The energy required for the polypropylene box is significantly higher than that for the bags, necessitating multiple uses to offset this difference. Each use of the box also requires energy for washing, complicating the calculation of total uses needed for justification. The initial calculation shows that the box must be used a certain number of times to compensate for its higher energy life cycle, but the washing energy adds complexity, leading to an asymptotic relationship in total uses. A proper mathematical model is needed to accurately reflect the cumulative energy costs of repeated washing alongside the initial energy comparison.
smalveh
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Hi, I have to calculate the amount of times a 76g polypropylene lunchbox must be used in order to justify its purchase over disposable 2g polyethylene snaplock bags, in terms of the life cycle energy of the two products. However each time the polypropylene box is used it must be washed using 500ml of hot water.

Known Data:
Energy life cycle of 2g of polyethylene = 64.2kJ (Ebag)
Energy life cycle of 76g of polypropylene = 5 578.4KJ (Ebox)
Energy required to heat 500ml water from 15 °C to 45 °C = 64.6KJ (Ewash)

So now I understand the amount of times the box must be used just to make up for the energy life cycle difference between it and the bags is Usesinitial = Ebox/Ebag
But where I get stuck is trying to calculate the amount of times the box must be used in order to make up for the energy lost washing the box.

This is what I've tried so far:
Usesinitial= Ebox/Ebag
Usesdue to washing = Usesinitial * Ewash/Ebag

Now what confuses me is that every time the box must be used it must be washed, thus expending more energy, because of this loss of energy the box must be used again and then washed again, it seems to me this will go on for ever or more realistically the total uses will asymptote. How do I form a proper mathematical relationship from this.
Thanks for your help.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I'm not too sure, do you think you use the calorific value and if so, how?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top