Limit as 'constant' approaches infinity

In summary: A then it is valid to use L'Hôpital's rule?Yes, the derivative of the sinc function with respect to A will be valid to use L'Hôpital's rule.
  • #1
omlatte1
9
0

Homework Statement



Determine limA→∞(sinc(x/2A))

Homework Equations



I would use L'Hôpital's rule, but I'm not sure if it is valid in this case as the function is that of x, not A. I want to know if it's valid to treat x as constant and take derivatives with respect to A and evaluate as A->inf.


The Attempt at a Solution



limA→∞(sinc(x/2A))=limA→∞(sin(x/2A)/(x/2A))
=limA→0(sin((x/2)A)/((x/2)A))
=limA→0(cos((x/2)A))
=1

Is this correct usage of L'Hôpital's rule?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Perhaps I should include that the sinc function is the Fourier transform of the ractangle function of height A and width 1/A, hence why A is 'constant'...but not...in this question.
 
  • #3
Wouldn't the just be zero. If you treat x as a constant then no matter its value, having A in the denominator will push it toward zero.
 
  • #4
When you have a sin(x/A) what changes with the sin function as you vary A?
 
  • #5
I believe you are correct cp255, I am just lacking in formal proof.

cpscdave - x is inversely proportional to A, so the sin function approaches zero, but, the denominator of the sinc function (it is the sinc function not the sin function) approaches zero also...need some sort of formal analysis to determine which dominates.
 
  • #6
hence l'hopitals rule, as sinc(x/2A)=sin(x/2A)/(x/2A)
 
  • #7
Well I'm trying to propose a way for you to verify that the application of L'Hôpital's

With the Sinc function changing A alters the period So when A hits ∞ I'll have an infinite period no? Which in turn verify's your answer

Or conversly in the time domain setting A to ∞ would result in a dirac pulse, the Fourier transform of which is 1
 
  • #8
Yes that is a good point, i like the analysis. I guess what I would like to know now then, is whether I can indeed use l'hopitals rule in the way I have, using A as the variable in the analysis of the limit(taking derivatives with respect to A), even though sinc was originally a function of x.
 
  • #9
I don't see any reason why you can't as you are doing the derrivate of the varible that's changing in this case :)
The fact that you can verify the answer in a few other methods lends credance to this as well :)
 
  • #10
omlatte1, you title is misleading. In your limit A is not a constant - it is a variable. In the limit process, x is held constant.
 
  • #11
It it? I think many other people like me who don't exactly understand how it works would phrase the question in a similar manner, hence the quotes for constant.
 
  • #12
omlatte1 said:
It it? I think many other people like me who don't exactly understand how it works would phrase the question in a similar manner, hence the quotes for constant.
The operative phrase here is "don't exactly understand how it works."

In this limit, limA→∞(sinc(x/2A)), A is what is changing, not x.

This is exactly the same as writing
$$\lim_{x \to \infty} sinc(\frac C {2x})$$

I don't believe you would be fooled into thinking x is a constant (or 'constant' as you wrote it).

BTW, when you write x/2A, what you're really writing is (x/2) * A. If you mean x/(2A), you need parentheses.
 
  • #13
A is what I said was constant,and it is, with respect to the transform of the original rectangle function, others in this thread have quoted x as being constant. This also is valid when speaking of l'hopitals rule in part because the partial derivative of sinc with respect to A was taken.

Also you write: "A is what is changing, not x" then "I don't believe you would be fooled into thinking x is a constant"
a confusing post at best. By the way do not assume what you think I know and whether or not I am making true or purposely false statements with respect to semantics. Your post implies I am lying and is completely beyond the limits of your purpose in this forum. Keep it to yourself.
 
  • #14
omlatte1 said:
A is what I said was constant,and it is, with respect to the transform of the original rectangle function, others in this thread have quoted x as being constant.
But none of that has anything to do with the limit you posted, in which A is changing. That's what ##lim_{A \to \infty} <something>## means. If something is changing, it is NOT constant.
omlatte1 said:
This also is valid when speaking of l'hopitals rule in part because the partial derivative of sinc with respect to A was taken.
If you take a derivative or partial derivative of some expression with respect to A, the clear implication is that A is changing (not constant), and any other quantities are held fixed.
omlatte1 said:
Also you write: "A is what is changing, not x" then "I don't believe you would be fooled into thinking x is a constant"
a confusing post at best.
It shouldn't be confusing if you read (and quoted) all of what I said.
omlatte1 said:
By the way do not assume what you think I know and whether or not I am making true or purposely false statements with respect to semantics.
You are completely misreading what I said. I did not say or imply or suggest in any way that you were making purposely false statements. Period.
omlatte1 said:
Your post implies I am lying and is completely beyond the limits of your purpose in this forum.
My post does nothing of the kind, and I don't see how you can possibly infer that.
 
  • #15
This was solved a while back now.
 
  • #16
omlatte1 said:
A is what I said was constant,and it is, with respect to the transform of the original rectangle function, others in this thread have quoted x as being constant. This also is valid when speaking of l'hopitals rule in part because the partial derivative of sinc with respect to A was taken.

Also you write: "A is what is changing, not x"
He said that in post 10 in which x was held constant and A was "going to infinity".

then "I don't believe you would be fooled into thinking x is a constant"
He said that in post 12 where he had given a different example

a confusing post at best.
It would have been if if it had been a single post- but it wasn't, it was two different posts saying different things.

By the way do not assume what you think I know and whether or not I am making true or purposely false statements with respect to semantics. Your post implies I am lying and is completely beyond the limits of your purpose in this forum. Keep it to yourself.
We can only assume you know what you say. Mark44 was correcting your use of a word and trying to clarify for others. I cannot imagine how you think that implies you were "lying". It only implies that you were mistaken.
 
  • #17
Knowledge was in reference to the question, funnily enough I did not know the answer to my own question.
 

1. What is the concept of "limit as 'constant' approaches infinity"?

The concept refers to the behavior of a function as the value of a constant variable approaches infinity. In other words, it is the value that a function approaches as its input variable becomes larger and larger.

2. How is this concept used in real-world applications?

This concept is used in various fields of science, such as physics, chemistry, and engineering, to model and analyze real-world phenomena. It helps in understanding the behavior of systems that involve continuously increasing or decreasing variables.

3. What is the difference between a finite limit and an infinite limit?

A finite limit means that the value of the function approaches a specific value as the input variable approaches a certain value. An infinite limit means that the value of the function becomes infinitely large or small as the input variable approaches a certain value.

4. Can a function have different limits as the input variable approaches different values?

Yes, a function can have different limits as the input variable approaches different values. This is known as a two-sided limit, where the function approaches different values depending on whether the input variable approaches from the left or the right side.

5. How can we determine the limit as 'constant' approaches infinity?

To determine the limit as 'constant' approaches infinity, we can use various methods, such as substitution, factoring, and L'Hôpital's rule. We can also use a graph or a table to visualize the behavior of the function as the input variable increases towards infinity.

Similar threads

  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
23
Views
1K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
20
Views
1K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
284
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
824
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
865
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
8
Views
665
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
8
Views
919
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
1K
Back
Top