Nasty integral - which piece of technology to trust?

[tatiana_eggs]

Nasty integral -- which piece of technology to trust?

Homework Statement

indefinite integral: e^x / (e^2x + 9) dx
Technology is allowed to solve it.

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

My trusty TI-89 says (pi/540)arctan((e^3x)/3)

while two different online integral calculators came up with (1/3log(e))*arctan((e^3x)/3)

What do you think? Which is right/should I trust? Should I just do it by hand? If so, what method do you recommend?

Thanks

 

[╔(σ_σ)╝]

u=e^x

 

[tatiana_eggs]

Hmm, I don't know if it's just by foggy memory of Calc II but that substitution doesn't seem to help it at all.

 

[Dickfore]

Make the subst [itex]e^{x} = 3 u[/tex] and your integral will be converted to a table one. none of the answers is correct.[/itex]

 

[statdad]

What relationship is there between $$e^{2x}$$ and $$e^x$$? That should help with the integral and the substitution.

 

[tatiana_eggs]

Thanks you two, I am starting to get it, but I am running into trouble.

So far, 3u=e^x, du=?dx -- should I take du/dx of e^x/3 and get du = e^x dx? But if I do that then I get an e^x in my integral below.

integral: 3u / (9u^2 + 9)

 

[Dickfore]

what is du?

 

[tatiana_eggs]

The derivative of u. I thought I had to take the derivative of my subsitution and solve for dx to sub that back into my integral.

 

[Dickfore]

Write what you get for du.

 

[Hurkyl]

I think your trusty TI-89 calculated exactly what you told it to calculate, rather than what you meant to calculate. Is it in degree mode, perchance, instead of radian mode?

 

[Dickfore]

yes :)

 

[tatiana_eggs]

so I got du = (e^x)/3 dx. What do I do with this expression? I thought I was supposed to solve for dx, and plug that into my integral with my u's. Is that not right?

integral: 3u / (9u^2 + 9) * 3 / (e^x) du

 

[tatiana_eggs]

Hurkyl, it was in radian mode.

 

[Dickfore]

Oh, so then the default output of the arctangent function for TI-89 is in degrees.

 

[tatiana_eggs]

Oh wow, I just did it in degree mode and it produced the answer consistent with the back of the book.

 

[tatiana_eggs]

Thanks Statdad, Dickfore and Hurkyl, so very much!

 

[tatiana_eggs]

Oh and I finally figured out the substitution thing. I realized I didn't need to sub 3u into the numerator

 

[╔(σ_σ)╝]

u=e^x
du=e^xdx
Your integral becomes
1/(u^2 +9) which is the antiderievative of (1/3)arctan(u/3)...