Need help finishing Physics Problem, almost have answer.?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Frogger Man
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Physics
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving a physics problem involving two positive and two negative charges placed at the corners of a square. The user calculated the forces between the charges using Coulomb's law but encountered issues with the final answer. It was determined that the calculations were off by orders of magnitude, particularly in the unit conversions from microCoulombs to milliCoulombs. After recalculating with the correct units, the user arrived at a new value for the force. The conversation emphasizes the importance of unit accuracy in physics calculations.
Frogger Man
Messages
14
Reaction score
0
Two Q = +5.85 mC charges are placed at opposite corners of a square d = 1.2 m on each side, and -Q = -5.85 mC charges are placed at the remaining corners, as shown in the figure.

I labeled the square A, B, C, D from top left to bottem left.

Fba = k • QA • QB / dBA2
Fca = k • QA • QC / dCA2
Fda = k • QA • QD / dDA2

Fba= -.21365
Fca= .10683
Fda= -.21365

I used the pythagorean therum to find Fba+Fda, and got .302, and then i subracted .10683 from that, but that was not the correct answer.

Any suggestions?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What are you asked to find?
 
Yea, probably should have put that in,

Determine the magnitude and direction of the force on each charge.
 
Frogger Man said:
Fba= -.21365
Fca= .10683
Fda= -.21365
What units are these in?
 
They should be in Newtons
 
Redo the calculations. (You are off by orders of magnitude.)
 
Fba = k • QA • QB / dBA2
Fba = (8.99*10^9 • (5.85)*10^-6 • (-5.85)*10^-6) / 1.2^2
Fba = (-.30766) / (1.44)
Fba = -.21365

Are my numbers off, or just my sign, or both?
 
Ah... you're using mC to mean microCoulombs. (Better to use \mu C.) In that case, the numbers look OK to me.
 
I think you might be right, it should be milli. I will try that.
 
  • #10
I got it, 195872.2698.

Thanks for your help.
 
Back
Top