Negative Energy of Bound Bodies & Hydrogen Atom

In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of negative energy associated with bound bodies such as planets and the hydrogen atom. It is explained that in classical mechanics, the zero point of energy is arbitrary, and the distinction between positive and negative energy is also arbitrary. The total energy of a system is the difference between the energy required to bring it from infinity to its current state and the energy required to remove it from its current state. The concept of warm holes, which involve negative energy, is briefly mentioned. The article "Negative Energy, Wormholes and Warp Drive" discusses how energy is never created or destroyed, but rather moves and changes form, similar to water. However, energy stored in gravitational fields is inherently negative in order to conserve the total energy
  • #1
SANGHERA.JAS
50
0
What is meant by total negative energy associated with bound bodies like planets. and also total energy of the hydrogen atom is negative. I wonder how it could be? Because I believe whatever negative energy may be, It must only be associated with bound systems, and I don't think that an isolated H-atom (as what we assume during its derivation) is bound to anything. Finally how it differs from negative energy associated with warm holes?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
In classical mechanics the zero point of energy is arbitrary - and consequently the distinction between positive and negative energy is arbitrary.

Recall a ball near the surface of the Earth has potential energy approximately m*g*h (m=mass, g=acceleration due to gravity=9.8m/s^2, h=height). Where do we measure the height from? The ground? The center of the earth? The table the ball is sitting on?
It doesn't matter! These will all give different potential energies, but only differences in energy are physical.

That being said we conventionally for gravity and electrostatics we take the zero of energy as when all the particles are infinitely far from each other (because potential energy drops off as 1/r).

So for example consider the sun and Earth system, this has some negative gravitational potential energy, -E. E is the energy that would be released in moving the Earth from infinitely far away (through free space) to its current distance from the sun.
Conversely E is the energy that would be required to push the Earth out of the sun's influence.

Now consider an isolated H-atom - it is a bounded system. The electron is bound to the proton! (In a very similar way to how the Earth is bound to the Sun). What you would call the total energy is the energy released when we add an electron to a proton to make Hydrogen. Conversely it is the energy required to rip an electron away from the hydrogen atom.

I have no idea what a warm hole is, but I assume it's a whole different kettle of fish.
 
  • #3
fantispug said:
I have no idea what a warm hole is, but I assume it's a whole different kettle of fish.
Thank You for yours reply.
In general relativity there are three type of extreme bodies, theoratically predicted. One is black hole which you already know, second is white hole in which nothing can ever fall and hence "white" & third is warm hole, which has some properties which allow time travel. Theorist like THOMAS A. ROMAN and LAWRENCE H. FORD have predicted that to create a warm hole we will require negative energy which is different from negative energy mentioned above.
Followhttp://www.sciamdigital.com/index.cfm?fa=Products.ViewIssue&ISSUEID_CHAR=82D7E940-CBFE-4BD2-989F-A47BDEAACE1"
and read article Negative Energy, Wormholes and Warp Drive.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #4
energy is neither created nor destoyed. it merely moves from place to place and changes form. think of energy as being like water. we can move it from place to place and freeze or evaporiate it but the total amount remains the same. when measuring the level of wtater in a lake we can assign any number we want to any given level of water. if we assign a positive number to one level then it entirely possible that later the watter may drop to a level where we need negative numbers to describe it. but the water itself is always positive. there are no negative sheep and there is no negative water. the exception is energy stored in gravitational fields. this energy (and no other) is inherently negative. it has to be for the total energy of a gravitationally bound system to be conserved. energy stored in other kinds of fields is positive.
 

1. What is negative energy of bound bodies?

The negative energy of bound bodies refers to the energy state of an object or system that is lower than the baseline energy level. This can occur when an object or system is in a bound state, meaning that it is held together by some type of force, such as gravity or electromagnetic forces.

2. How is negative energy of bound bodies related to the hydrogen atom?

The hydrogen atom is an example of a bound body that can have negative energy. In the hydrogen atom, the negatively charged electron is bound to the positively charged proton by the electromagnetic force. This binding creates a negative energy state for the electron.

3. What causes the negative energy of bound bodies?

The negative energy of bound bodies is caused by the attractive forces between the particles that make up the system. These forces, such as gravity or electromagnetic forces, act to keep the particles bound together. As a result, the particles have a lower energy state than they would if they were not bound.

4. How is negative energy of bound bodies different from negative energy in general?

Negative energy of bound bodies is a specific type of negative energy that only applies to bound systems. In general, negative energy can refer to any energy state that is lower than the baseline energy level. This can include things like negative kinetic energy or negative potential energy.

5. Can negative energy of bound bodies be observed in real life?

Yes, negative energy of bound bodies can be observed in real life. The most common example is the binding energy of atoms and molecules, as seen in chemical reactions. Additionally, the negative energy of bound bodies is also observed in larger systems, such as stars and galaxies, where gravity acts as the binding force.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
949
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
1
Views
510
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
829
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
5
Views
914
  • Classical Physics
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
5
Views
882
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
727
Back
Top