Newton's Second law: Tension on Cable

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the tension in a cable supporting a 5.0 kg watermelon being accelerated upward at 2.0 m/s². Initially, the participant incorrectly calculated the tension as 10 N by only considering the mass and acceleration. Clarification was provided that the net force (Fnet) must account for both the tension in the cable and the gravitational force acting on the watermelon. After revising the approach, the correct equation was established, leading to the final tension in the cable being calculated as 59 N. The participant expressed gratitude for the assistance in resolving the confusion.
aatari
Messages
73
Reaction score
3
Hey guys is my solution correct for the question below?

1. Homework Statement

Consider a 5.0 kg watermelon that is being accelerated at 2.0 m/s2 [up] by a cable. Find the tension in the cable.

Homework Equations


Fcable = m.a

The Attempt at a Solution


Fcable = m.a
= 5.0 kg(2.0)
= 10N
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Your solution is incorrect. Newton's second law says Fnet = ma. Fnet is the sum of all the forces acting on the watermelon, not just the force from the cable.
 
kuruman said:
Your solution is incorrect. Newton's second law says Fnet = ma. Fnet is the sum of all the forces acting on the watermelon, not just the force from the cable.
Ok I am confused now. I thought Fnet = m.a
 
Or in this situation should it be Fcable +Fgravity
 
aatari said:
Or in this situation should it be Fcable +Fgravity
Yes, it should be as you say. Can you finish the problem now?
 
kuruman said:
Yes, it should be as you say. Can you finish the problem now?
Fcable = 10 N
Fgravity = -49N

Fcable + Fgravity = 10N - 49N
= 39 N [down]

Is this correst?
 
How do you figure Fcable = 10 N? It seems that you multiplied the acceleration by the mass and called that Fcable. We agreed that mass times acceleration is the net force. Write an expression for the net force as the sum of all the forces, set it equal to mass times acceleration and solve for Fcable.
 
kuruman said:
How do you figure Fcable = 10 N? It seems that you multiplied the acceleration by the mass and called that Fcable. We agreed that mass times acceleration is the net force. Write an expression for the net force as the sum of all the forces, set it equal to mass times acceleration and solve for Fcable.
I think I get it now.

So Fnet = Fcable + Fgravity
10N = Fcable - 49N
10N + 49N = Fcable
Fcable = 59N
 
Yes, you got it. :smile:
 
  • Like
Likes aatari
  • #10
kuruman said:
Yes, you got it. :smile:
Thanks for your help.
 
Back
Top