Partial Fraction Decomposition problem

5 replies · 3K views · last reply
sashab
Messages
12
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Evaluate ∫((secx)^2)/[((tanx)^2)+(3tanx)+2]

Homework Equations



Partial fraction decomposition

The Attempt at a Solution



So here's what I did:
Handwritten derivation evaluating the integral of sec^2 x over tan^2 x + 3 tan x + 2, substituting u = tan x and factoring the denominator as (u+2)(u+1), then splitting into partial fractions A/(u+2) + B/(u+1) and finding A = -1, B = 1, giving -ln|tan x + 2| + ln|tan x + 1|.


But this is incorrect. It says the correct answer is -2lnabs([itex]\frac{1}{2tanx+3}[/itex]+[itex]\sqrt{4(tanx+3/2)^{2}-1}[/itex]), which was achieved by making the same u-substitution, completing the square, and then doing a trig substitution. I'm not sure why my method is incorrect. Any help would be great, thanks!
 
I agree with your answer (and method!). Seems to me that the other answer is a decreasing function in the range 0 to 1, yet from the integral it should clearly be increasing. If you post all the working of the other method I'll see if I can find the error.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person
Ohh okay, I'm glad it's not incorrect then! Here's the other solution I was referring to :
Handwritten integral solution using the substitution x = tan t, showing the rewrite of 1/(x^2+3x+2) as 1/((x+3/2)^2 - 1/4), the trigonometric substitution steps, and the final result -2 ln|1/(2x+3) + sqrt(4(x+3/2)^2 - 1)| + C, then rewritten in terms of tan t.
 
haruspex said:
There's an error here: csc = 1/sec.
Ohh okay I see. Thanks so much for the help! Would you be willing to help me with another partial fraction decomposition question?
 
sashab said:
Ohh okay I see. Thanks so much for the help! Would you be willing to help me with another partial fraction decomposition question?
Sure, but post it in a new thread for all to see.