How Do You Calculate Pendulum Velocity Using Newton's Laws?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the velocity of a pendulum bob at the bottom of its path using Newton's Laws. The user initially derived the velocity using conservation of mechanical energy, arriving at the formula v = sqrt(2gL(1-cos(theta))). However, they are struggling to replicate this result using only Newton's Laws, specifically needing to integrate the tangential acceleration, which is -gsin(theta). Suggestions include using angular variables and relating velocity to the angle theta to form a differential equation. The conversation highlights the challenge of integrating acceleration in terms of theta and the need for a clearer approach to solve the problem.
cideraid
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
Been stuck on this problem for a bit. Anyways here it is:
A pendulum bob on an ideal string of length (L) is released from an angle (theta) with respect to the direction of gravity.
Determine the velocity of the bob at the bottom of its path in terms of (theta) using only Newton's Laws of motion.
The solution to the problem should reaffirm that the v=Sqrt(2gL(1-cos(theta))) which one gets using the equations for conservation of mechanical energy.

*Currently I'm taking AP analytical physics, and we've covered dynamics, kinematics, energy, and uniform circular motion, but nothing like torque or angular velocity.


So far, I figured out that the tangential force on the pendulum is equal to: -mgsin(theta).
since ma=-mgsin(theta), the tangential acceleration is equal to: -gsin(theta).
So I tried to find the velocity by taking the integral of that, but it's nothing close to what the problem says I'm supposed to get.
I think I'm missing something really big here, but i don't know what...
 
Physics news on Phys.org
No need to drag forces into this. It says right in the problem to "use conservation of mechanical E"

Write out the formula for that first and see what you have.
 
Yea that's actually the second part of the problem which I already solved doing:
1/2(mv)^2=mgh
1/2(v)^2=gh
v=sqrt(2gh)

so to get h, I found the vertical displacement of the pendulum using trig:
so so a right triangle which has sides (L, L-h, and some hypotenuse)
cos(theta)=L/(L-h)
solving for h, h=-Lcos(theta)+L
factoring out L, h=L(1-cos(theta))
plugging that back in v=sqrt(2gL(1-cos(theta)))

Anyways, that was the second part of the problem, but the first part of the problem states that one needs to derive the same formula using only the Newton's laws of motion, which is the part I'm stuck on...
 
Last edited:
Oops. Sorry. My fault. Let me have another look. :redface:
 
I don't know why I cannot remember how to do this! You are correct in saying there IS an integral involved. But I am coming up blank here... perhaps someone else can chime in here.
 
Yea, I was thinking about approaching this using non-uniform circular motion; finding the tangential and radial acceleration at the bottom of the pendulum's path. Then using pythagorean theorem to find the acceleration. I would then take the integral of that in order to get the velocity.
The trouble is I'm having trouble finding the radial acceleration.
tangential acceleration should be -gsin(theta)?
 
cideraid said:
I think I'm missing something really big here, but i don't know what...

Your variable of motion should be theta, just like you would have had x for linear motion. I find it better to just use the angular position, angular velocity and angular acceleration for these problems. You can also work by converting theta into a tangential distance variable.

That said, there is nothing wrong with your force equation. How did you do the integration?
 
Yes; however, I chose downward to be positive to simplify the calculations. Thus I have a=gsin(theta)
 
Well i took the integral of just the tangential acceleration which i then get -gcos(x)+C, but now thinking about it, I need to also take into account the radial acceleration (V^2)/r?
 
Last edited:
  • #10
cideraid said:
Well i took the integral of just the tangential acceleration which i then get -gcos(x)+C, but now thinking about it, I need to also take into account the radial acceleration (V^2)/r?

What I don't like about this is that the integral is:

a=\frac{dV}{dt}=-gsin\theta

thus

V=\int-gsin\theta\, dt

however in order to integrate this, you need sin(theta) as a function of t
or
a as a function of theta
 
  • #11
Deleted. Salad said all the relevant stuff.
 
  • #12
hmmm that clarifies somethings for me
 
  • #13
I wish I could be of more help, but I am all tuckered out. Hopefully Dick will chime in, I notice he is online.
 
  • #14
thanks for everything so far though
 
Last edited:
  • #15
Try relating V to \theta - that way you can obtain a differential equation for \theta and hopefully be able to solve it.
 
Back
Top