Physics or Engineering? Job Possibilities in Aerospace Industry

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the job possibilities in the aerospace industry for individuals with degrees in physics versus mechanical or aerospace engineering. Participants explore the relevance of theoretical physics in engineering roles and the potential career paths available for physics graduates.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest that a physics major may not be necessary for a career in the aerospace industry, emphasizing the differences between physics and engineering degrees.
  • Others argue that there is significant overlap between aerospace and mechanical engineering, making a double major a viable option for those interested in both fields.
  • Several participants express that while theoretical physics is appealing, pursuing a degree in aerospace or mechanical engineering may be more practical for entering the aerospace industry.
  • One participant notes that engineering does not exclude theoretical aspects, and some engineers engage with theoretical concepts despite the perception that they do not.
  • Concerns are raised about the job market for physics majors, with some participants stating that physics graduates may find it challenging to secure engineering roles compared to engineering graduates.
  • It is mentioned that physics majors can find roles assisting engineers, but they may not be involved in direct engineering tasks.
  • Teaching physics is suggested as a potential career path for physics graduates.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the necessity of a physics degree for careers in aerospace, with some advocating for engineering degrees while others believe physics graduates can find relevant roles. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the best educational path for entering the aerospace industry.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight the differences in educational focus between physics and engineering, suggesting that the applicability of a physics degree in engineering contexts may depend on specific job roles and individual career goals.

Rose53
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Hi,

I first started a thread about being interested in aerospace engineering.

Err.. now when I think about it, I think I like pure theoretical physics as well. I was looking at one of the colleges course load for the physics major, and I really wanted to take those classes.

Eventually I want to end up working in the aerospace industry, in either research, design or engineering.

Maybe I'm brainstorming right now, but what are the job possibilities in the aerospace industry with a physics major? Mechanical engineering major? ...Just asking.

-Rose53
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Rose53 said:
Hi,

I first started a thread about being interested in aerospace engineering.

Err.. now when I think about it, I think I like pure theoretical physics as well. I was looking at one of the colleges course load for the physics major, and I really wanted to take those classes.

Eventually I want to end up working in the aerospace industry, in either research, design or engineering.

Maybe I'm brainstorming right now, but what are the job possibilities in the aerospace industry with a physics major? Mechanical engineering major? ...Just asking.

-Rose53


If you want to end up working in the aerospace industry, then there's really no need to major in physics. They are pretty different degrees, despite some math and physical application overlap. A lot of students at my school do a double major in aerospace and mechanical engineering. There is a *lot* of overlap between those degrees, unlike physics and aerospace.
 
If you like pure theoretical physics but want to work in the aerospace industry, then become an aerospace or mechanical engineer. I personally am interested in pure mathematics despite being an aerospace engineering major. But I'll leave pure mathematics to be a hobby of mine. I'll buy advanced math books and bug the hell out of PF when I get stuck once I'm done with my engineering degree. I recommend a similar path for you.
 
Yeah, one thing I learned while working with engineering grad students this summer is that engineering really doesn't exclude theoretical aspects as much as I thought it did. It is true that the majority of engineers don't deal with very much theory, and it's easy to interpret that as "if I become an engineer, I can't do theoretical things." But it turns out that that doesn't mean that you can't do a lot of theory as an engineer, it's just that most people just don't.
 
nlsherrill said:
If you want to end up working in the aerospace industry, then there's really no need to major in physics. They are pretty different degrees, despite some math and physical application overlap. A lot of students at my school do a double major in aerospace and mechanical engineering. There is a *lot* of overlap between those degrees, unlike physics and aerospace.

Well one of the reasons I asked is because I'm looking into 2 colleges. One offers both aerospace and mechanical eng majors, and the other only offers mechanical eng. Both colleges offer physics.

So there are no jobs in the engineering field with a physics major?

What kind of jobs can you get with a physics major?
 
Angry Citizen said:
If you like pure theoretical physics but want to work in the aerospace industry, then become an aerospace or mechanical engineer. I personally am interested in pure mathematics despite being an aerospace engineering major. But I'll leave pure mathematics to be a hobby of mine. I'll buy advanced math books and bug the hell out of PF when I get stuck once I'm done with my engineering degree. I recommend a similar path for you.

Hmm ok.. I guess I can seek pure theoretical physics as a hobby and pursue engineering. Makes sense.
 
Rose53 said:
Well one of the reasons I asked is because I'm looking into 2 colleges. One offers both aerospace and mechanical eng majors, and the other only offers mechanical eng. Both colleges offer physics.

So there are no jobs in the engineering field with a physics major?

What kind of jobs can you get with a physics major?

I'm sure a physics graduate could land a job in engineering...but not easier than an engineer could.

There's plenty of threads on this forum about what jobs you can get as a physics major. I wouldn't recommend getting a physics degree if you are planning on not going further than undergraduate though, because you aren't going to get a job remotely related to physics easier than an engineer is(probably)
 
Rose53 said:
Eventually I want to end up working in the aerospace industry, in either research, design or engineering.

I work for a manufacturing company that designs technologically advanced machinery. My company has both a research department and an engineering department. We work very closely. The engineers curse the researchers for having no practical sense, and the researchers curse the engineers for not putting absurd theory into immediate practice.

Rose53 said:
So there are no jobs in the engineering field with a physics major?

What kind of jobs can you get with a physics major?

Yes, there are. The type I mentioned above. You will not be engineering anything, you will be assisting engineers. The education of an engineer covers some very specific points that are of little interest to a physicist.

A physics major can always become a physics teacher. This seems to be the perpetual cycle.

Remember, physics is simply applied mathematics, and engineering is simply applied physics.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K