Proof: Height of Vertical Mast on River Banks

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around proving the height of a vertical mast located on the north bank of a river, with angles of elevation measured from two points on the south bank. The initial equations set the height of the mast as h, using trigonometric relationships based on the angles α and β from points A and B, respectively. A series of calculations employing Pythagorean theorem leads to the expression for h, but confusion arises regarding the correctness of the derived formula. Participants suggest further exploration of the relationships between the angles and the height to clarify the solution. Ultimately, the discussion emphasizes the need for careful manipulation of trigonometric identities to arrive at the correct height formula.
Appleton
Messages
91
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A vertical mast stands on the north bank of a river with straight parallel banks running from east to west. The angle of elevation of the top of the mast is α when measured from a point A on the south bank distant 3a to the east of the mast and β when measured from another point B on the south bank distant 5a to the west mast. prove that the height of the mast is
4a/(cot^2\beta-cot^2\alpha)^\frac{1}{2}

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


Let the height of the mast be h.
Let C be the base of the mast.
Let D be the point at which the perpendicular from BA to C divides BA.

<br /> BC = \frac{h}{tan β}\\\\<br /> CA = \frac{h}{tan α}\\\\<br />
By Pythagoras' theorem

<br /> CD = \sqrt{(\frac{h}{tan β})^2 - (5a)^2)}\\\\<br /> CD = \sqrt{(\frac{h}{tan α})^2 - (3a)^2)}\\\\<br />
So

<br /> \sqrt{(\frac{h}{tan β})^2 - (5a)^2)} = \sqrt{(\frac{h}{tan α})^2 - (3a)^2)}\\\\\<br /> (\frac{h}{tan β})^2 - (\frac{h}{tan α})^2 = (5a)^2 - (3a)^2\\\\<br /> \frac{h^2 tan^2 α - h^2 tan^2 β }{(tan^2 β) (tan^2 α)} = 16a^2\\<br /> h = 4a\sqrt{\frac{(tan^2 β) (tan^2 α)}{tan^2 α - tan^2 β }}<br />

At this point I figure that either the question is floored or I've made a mistake. Usually it's the latter.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Appleton said:

Homework Statement


A vertical mast stands on the north bank of a river with straight parallel banks running from east to west. The angle of elevation of the top of the mast is α when measured from a point A on the south bank distant 3a to the east of the mast and β when measured from another point B on the south bank distant 5a to the west mast. prove that the height of the mast is
4a/(cot^2\beta-cot^2\alpha)^\frac{1}{2}

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


Let the height of the mast be h.
Let C be the base of the mast.
Let D be the point at which the perpendicular from BA to C divides BA.

<br /> BC = \frac{h}{tan β}\\\\<br /> CA = \frac{h}{tan α}\\\\<br />
By Pythagoras' theorem

<br /> CD = \sqrt{(\frac{h}{tan β})^2 - (5a)^2)}\\\\<br /> CD = \sqrt{(\frac{h}{tan α})^2 - (3a)^2)}\\\\<br />
So

<br /> \sqrt{(\frac{h}{tan β})^2 - (5a)^2)} = \sqrt{(\frac{h}{tan α})^2 - (3a)^2)}\\\\\<br /> (\frac{h}{tan β})^2 - (\frac{h}{tan α})^2 = (5a)^2 - (3a)^2\\\\<br /> \frac{h^2 tan^2 α - h^2 tan^2 β }{(tan^2 β) (tan^2 α)} = 16a^2\\<br /> h = 4a\sqrt{\frac{(tan^2 β) (tan^2 α)}{tan^2 α - tan^2 β }}<br />

At this point I figure that either the question is floored or I've made a mistake. Usually it's the latter.
... or you have to take this a bit further.

What is ##\displaystyle\ \left(\frac{(tan^2 β) (tan^2 α)}{tan^2 α - tan^2 β }\right)^{-1}\ ## ?
 
SammyS said:
... or you have to take this a bit further.

What is ##\displaystyle\ \left(\frac{(tan^2 β) (tan^2 α)}{tan^2 α - tan^2 β }\right)^{-1}\ ## ?

Ah yes, I'm kicking myself. Thanks for the nudge.
 
Last edited:
I picked up this problem from the Schaum's series book titled "College Mathematics" by Ayres/Schmidt. It is a solved problem in the book. But what surprised me was that the solution to this problem was given in one line without any explanation. I could, therefore, not understand how the given one-line solution was reached. The one-line solution in the book says: The equation is ##x \cos{\omega} +y \sin{\omega} - 5 = 0##, ##\omega## being the parameter. From my side, the only thing I could...
Back
Top