Question regarding tension in a string.

  • Thread starter Thread starter p75213
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    String Tension
AI Thread Summary
The tension in the string is not simply the weight of the hanging mass multiplied by gravity, especially when the mass is accelerating. In the given scenario, the tension must account for the angular acceleration of the spool, leading to a calculated tension of 100.6 N, which is greater than the weight of the mass. This discrepancy indicates that if tension equaled the weight, the mass would be in equilibrium and not falling. The discussion emphasizes the importance of considering both tension and acceleration in dynamic systems. The calculations highlight the need to reassess the initial assumptions about tension in accelerating scenarios.
p75213
Messages
93
Reaction score
0
I have a cylinder wound with string. The free end of the string has a weight dangling from it. Is the tension in the string simply mass of the weight*gravity?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Ignoring the weight of the string, then the tension in the free part of the string is equal to the weight (mass x gravity).
 
A cylindrical spool with mass 0.5kg and radius 0.5m is wrapped with 4m of string. A 5kg mass is hung from the end of the string. How fast will the spool be rotating when all of the string has been pulled off?

angular velocity^2= (initial angular velocity)^2 +2*(angular acceleration)*theta.
omega^2=initial_omega^2+2*alpha*theta
initial angular velocity=0
theta=8
omega^2=2*alpha*8
Find angular acceleration (alpha).


Let T be the tension in the string.
T-mg=ma
T-5*9.8=5a
T-49=5a
T-49=5r*alpha (tangental accel = r*alpha)
T-49=2.5*alpha (a)
----------------------------------
Torque=I*alpha
Torque=rT
I*alpha=rT
0.0625alpha=0.5T
T=0.125alpha
----------------------------------
Substitute T=0.125alpha in (a)
0.125alpha-49=2.5*alpha
-2.375alpha=49
alpha=-20.63rad/s^2
------------------------------------
omega=sqr(2*20.63*8)
omega =18.17rad/s
------------------------------------
That's the worked solution. Now let's look at T - equation (a)
T-49=2.5*alpha
T=2.5*alpha+49
T=100.6N
I would have thought T was equal to mg=5*9.8=49N
 
p75213 said:
I have a cylinder wound with string. The free end of the string has a weight dangling from it. Is the tension in the string simply mass of the weight*gravity?
No, not if the mass is accelerating.
 
p75213 said:
That's the worked solution. Now let's look at T - equation (a)
T-49=2.5*alpha
T=2.5*alpha+49
T=100.6N
I would have thought T was equal to mg=5*9.8=49N
Some points:
(1) Redo your solution as you've made an error. You have the tension greater than the weight of the hanging mass. That would mean the mass rises instead of falls!
(2) If the tension equaled mg, then the hanging mass would be in equilibrium.
(3) You can check your work by solving the problem using energy methods.
 
I see. That makes sense. That's what I was missing. The tension includes the acceleration of the string.
 
Doc Al said:
Some points:
(1) Redo your solution as you've made an error. You have the tension greater than the weight of the hanging mass. That would mean the mass rises instead of falls!
(2) If the tension equaled mg, then the hanging mass would be in equilibrium.
(3) You can check your work by solving the problem using energy methods.

Good points. Yes 100N didn't make sense to me either. (-2.575N)
 
Back
Top