Quick Question- carnot efficiency

  • Thread starter Thread starter trelek2
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Carnot Efficiency
AI Thread Summary
When calculating Carnot efficiency for an engine using multiple heat reservoirs, it is not valid to simply average the temperatures of the hot and cold reservoirs. A weighted average should be used, taking into account the flow rates and heat capacities of each reservoir. For example, if the majority of heat is sourced from a lower temperature reservoir, using a simple average could lead to an inaccurately high efficiency estimate. The efficiency calculation must reflect the actual energy extracted from or rejected to each reservoir. Accurate assessment of Carnot efficiency requires considering the specific contributions of each heat reservoir.
trelek2
Messages
86
Reaction score
0
Suppose an engine uses multiple heat reservoirs:

When calculating the carnot (maximum possible efficiency) is it valid to simply take the average of the temperatures of the hot reservoirs from which the heat is extracted as T(hot) and the average of the temperatures of the heat sinks to which heat is rejected as T(cold)??
(regardless of the amounts of energy Q rejected/extracted from each of the reservoirs)
 
Science news on Phys.org
I think you'd have to do a weighted average, based on flow rates and heat capacities or how they mix.

Put it this way if you have 99% flow from 400K reservoir and 1% from 1000K
using a average temp of 700K would give an unrealistically high efficieny.

This is all assuming I've undersood your original question correctly.
 
I agree with xxChrisxx; it all depends on how much heat is being removed from each reservoir per cycle.
 
Back
Top