In summary: Thank you for this additional information! It's interesting to see how these concepts were developed by different scientists at around the same time.
  • #1
21joanna12
126
2
I am teaching myself thermodynamics (and really enjoying it!) but am slightly confused about Carnot's engine. From the equation efficiency=1-T(cold reservoir)/T(hot reservoir), I see that the most efficient engine is one where the difference in temperature between the cold and hot reservoirs is the greatest. However I also read this:
"It was Carnot who realized that the most efficient heat engine of all was a ‘reversible’ heat engine. In other words – one that got the same amount of work out of the heat transfer as would be needed to operate a perfect fridge to undo its operation.

In order to do this, it is necessary for all the heat transfers (between one object and another) to take place with as small a temperature difference as possible. If this is not done, heat will flow from hot objects to cold – a process which could have been used to do work, but wasn’t. Therefore not enough work will be done to enable the fridge to return the heat to the hot object. "

And to me this Implies that the most efficient engine is where the temperature different is smallest because then less heat flows straight from the hot to cold reservoir without being used to do work.

So my first question is about the above, but I also wanted to ask about how Carnot's engine links to the third law of thermodynamics. I know That the equations for Carnot's engine are supposed to somehow demonstrate that absolute zero can never be reached in a finite number of steps, but I don't understand how?

Thank you in advance :)
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
21joanna12 said:
I
And to me this Implies that the most efficient engine is where the temperature different is smallest because then less heat flows straight from the hot to cold reservoir without being used to do work.
You have to distinguish between the difference in temperature between the hot and cold reservoir, and the temperature difference between the working substance and either reservoir when heat is transferred. The former gives the efficiency of the cycle, while the latter is required to make the cycle reversible. The temperature of the working substance must be brought to an infinitesimal ##\delta T## below that of the hot reservoir when receiving heat from it, and then have its temperature lowered to ##\delta T## above that of the cold reservoir to dump heat in it. Both serve to inihbit the creation of "extra" entropy, which reduces the efficiency.

21joanna12 said:
So my first question is about the above, but I also wanted to ask about how Carnot's engine links to the third law of thermodynamics. I know That the equations for Carnot's engine are supposed to somehow demonstrate that absolute zero can never be reached in a finite number of steps, but I don't understand how?
I'm not sure if this is the best explanation, but in a refrigerator, you need to lower the temperature of the working substance below that of the cold reservoir you are cooling down, and therefore would require a temperature below 0 K to lower the temperature of the cold reservoir to 0 K, which is of course impossible.
 
  • Like
Likes 21joanna12
  • #3
DrClaude said:
The temperature of the working substance must be brought to an infinitesimal ##\delta T## below that of the hot reservoir when receiving heat from it, and then have its temperature lowered to ##\delta T## above that of the cold reservoir to dump heat in it. Both serve to inihbit the creation of "extra" entropy, which reduces the efficiency.

Thank you so much for your reply! I like the refrigerator explanation!

But I was wondering if you could explain the above further? Why would the temperature difference between two objects being infinitesimal for maximum work being done? Why would there be extra entropy created otherwise, and why would the extra entropy reduce the efficiency? I apologise the load of questions! I don't want to burden you with so many, but I haven't found any good websites explaining this...
 
  • #4
21joanna12 said:
But I was wondering if you could explain the above further? Why would the temperature difference between two objects being infinitesimal for maximum work being done? Why would there be extra entropy created otherwise, and why would the extra entropy reduce the efficiency?
The change in entropy related to a transfer of heat into or out of a system is
$$
dS \geq \frac{Q}{T}
$$
where the equality holds only in the quasistatic or reversible case. Otherwise, the irreversibility means that something additional is going one with the system (it is not simply converting the heat into expansion work), and that means a greater production of entropy.

Then, consider an amount ##Q## of heat leaving a system at ##T_1## to another at ##T_2 < T_1##. The entropy of system 1 is decreased by ##\Delta S_1 = - Q / T_1##, while the entropy of system 2 increases by ##\Delta S_2 = Q / T_2##. The total change in entropy of the two system combined is
$$
\Delta S = Q \left( \frac{1}{T_2} - \frac{1}{T_1} \right) = Q \frac{T_1 - T_2}{T_1 T_2}
$$
The only way to have no change in entropy is to set ##T_1 = T_2##. The problem is that there can then be no heat exchange between the two (it contradicts ##T_2 < T_1##), so we consider ##T_1 = T_2 + \delta T##, with ##\delta T## infinitesimally small. This also shows that while the Carnot engine is the most efficient, it wouldn't be practical as it would take an infinitely long time to transfer the heat during the cycle.

21joanna12 said:
I apologise the load of questions! I don't want to burden you with so many, but I haven't found any good websites explaining this...
That's what PF is for!
 
  • Like
Likes 21joanna12
  • #5
Just a footnote. Doesn't add to excellent answers already given, except to point out a rather nice 'symmetry'…

Conduction of heat down a rod: heat out = heat in. Investigated mathematically by Fourier (c 1820)

Reversible heat engine: entropy out = entropy in. Investigated by Carnot (c 1820)

Two French men, working at about the same time, investigating what might be called opposite extremes of thermal processes. It should be noted, though, that Carnot didn't have the concept of entropy and doesn't even seem to have appreciated energy conservation – no reason why he should have done - these ideas developed later.
 
  • Like
Likes 21joanna12

1. What is the Carnot engine?

The Carnot engine is a theoretical thermodynamic cycle that describes the most efficient way to convert heat into work. It was developed by French physicist Sadi Carnot in the early 19th century.

2. How does the Carnot engine work?

The Carnot engine works by taking in heat from a high-temperature reservoir, using it to do work, and then releasing the remaining heat to a low-temperature reservoir. This process is repeated in a continuous cycle to produce mechanical work.

3. What is the efficiency of the Carnot engine?

The efficiency of the Carnot engine is defined as the ratio of the work output to the heat input, and it is equal to 1 - (TL/TH), where TL is the temperature of the low-temperature reservoir and TH is the temperature of the high-temperature reservoir.

4. What are the limitations of the Carnot engine?

The Carnot engine is a theoretical model and does not take into account practical limitations such as friction and heat loss. It also assumes that the process is reversible, which is not always the case in real-world applications.

5. How is the Carnot engine relevant in modern science?

The Carnot engine is relevant in modern science as it provides a theoretical benchmark for the maximum efficiency of heat engines, which is important in fields such as thermodynamics, engineering, and renewable energy research. It also helps to understand the principles of heat transfer and energy conversion in various systems.

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
758
Replies
2
Views
758
Replies
20
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
534
Replies
8
Views
12K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Back
Top