Resistance of A to B in Current Electricity Homework

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on finding the resistance between points A and B in a circuit diagram. Participants suggest simplifying the circuit by recognizing it forms an H shape and identifying a Wheatstone bridge, which allows for easier calculations. They recommend adding a DC voltage source to visualize current flow and using Kirchhoff's rules for analysis. The conversation emphasizes that, due to equal resistor values, complex transformations may not be necessary. Overall, the problem is acknowledged as complicated but solvable with the right approach.
1/2"
Messages
98
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Find the resistance between the A and B( image attached)

Homework Equations


The Attempt at a Solution


I could only simplify the diagram to this (2 attached pic) and i can't proceed any further since i can't identy find any parallel or series circuit/
 

Attachments

  • Untitled.jpg
    Untitled.jpg
    5.4 KB · Views: 549
  • Untitled2.png
    Untitled2.png
    1.2 KB · Views: 537
Physics news on Phys.org
You can unfold the first picture ... put points A and B in the corners, then unfold the triangle point A is on so A is outside the big triangle. See how to simplify it now?
No? Imagine a voltage source VAB between A and B and you have to find the total current drawn ... now do you get it?

You end up with the resistors forming an H ...
 
Last edited:
If you redraw it slightly differently you will see that by symetry one R has no voltage across it. So it can be removed without effecting the circuit. Makes it much easier to simplify further.
 
Simon Bridge said:
You can unfold the first picture ... put points A and B in the corners, then unfold the triangle point A is on so A is outside the big triangle. See how to simplify it now?
No? Imagine a voltage source VAB between A and B and you have to find the total current drawn ... now do you get it?

You end up with the resistors forming an H ...
resistance in between the parallel line of H... how do i combine it with others??:cry:
(Thanks A LOT for answering!:smile:)
 
1/2" said:
resistance in between the parallel line of H... how do i combine it with others??:cry:
(Thanks A LOT for answering!:smile:)

If you see carefully, there's a wheat stone bridge.
 
Pranav-Arora is correct - it's a Wheatstone bridge. How does one of those work?

You may understand it better if you add a DC voltage source to the diagram between A and B ... one of the resistors in the H does not carry a current: so you can just replace it with an open circuit.

If you still don't see it - use Kirkhoffs rules to find the relationship between VAB and the total current drawn, then Ohm's Law gets you the rest of the way.
 
sorry-deleting my post
 
Last edited:
@aziziwi: I'd have let 1/2" explore the situation in terms of existing knowledge more before introducing new ideas.

Since all the resistors have the same value, there is no need for the Y-Δ transform. Not that it isn't cool to know...

1/2" is about to discover that the problem only looks complicated. Worst case now is that he does a 3-loop/4-node Kirkhoff analysis ... which is lots of work, but sometimes you have to do something the long way before you realize where the shortcut is. Builds character ;)

I think we've gone as close as we can to actually doing the problem ... let's wait for 1/2" to get back to us.
 
Back
Top