Resistance, Voltage, and current

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the concepts of resistance, voltage, and current, particularly in relation to a homework question. Participants debate the definitions of static and dynamic resistance, noting that resistance cannot be defined for nonlinear components. The confusion arises from whether the question refers to static or dynamic resistance, which affects the correct answer choice. Clarifications are provided that static resistance is calculated as V/I, while dynamic resistance is derived from dV/dI. The conversation emphasizes the need for precise terminology in questions involving these concepts.
Cici2017

Homework Statement


Screen Shot 2017-07-22 at 4.46.56 pm.png


Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


I chose A, I understand how the resistance is the gradient, but if it is the gradient and the gradient is constant , shouldn't the resistance stay constant? (But the answer is B)
Please help~thanks a lot~
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I would have answered D. I can see a case to be made for A, but not for B.
 
Resistance cannot be defined for a nonlinear component.
There is "static resistance" and there is "dynamic resistance" but there is no "resistance".
 
rude man said:
Resistance cannot be defined for a nonlinear component.
There is "static resistance" and there is "dynamic resistance" but there is no "resistance".
Can you please explain a bit more? What does that mean in the context of this question? Thank you!
 
Cici2017 said:
Can you please explain a bit more? What does that mean in the context of this question? Thank you!
It means the question should have specified static or dynamic resistance.
 
Cici2017 said:
Can you please explain a bit more? What does that mean in the context of this question? Thank you!
V/I is the "static" or "chordal" resistance. If that is meant the answer would be D.
dV/dI is the "dynamic" or "differential" resistance. If that is meant the answer would be A if we take the right derivative at V0 but B if we take the left derivative.
In short, silly question.
 
Thank you~
 
Back
Top