Should I Delay My Engineering Classes Due to Poor Ratings?

AI Thread Summary
Concerns about the reliability of RateMyProfessors as a resource for evaluating engineering instructors are central to the discussion. Users express skepticism regarding the validity of low ratings, suggesting that they often stem from students who struggle with challenging coursework. Some participants emphasize the importance of seeking opinions from peers who have taken the courses, particularly those who are genuinely engaged with the material. They also recommend consulting tutors for insights on professors, as they have broader exposure to teaching styles. While some users acknowledge that bad ratings can sometimes reflect a professor's difficulty rather than their teaching ability, others argue that a pattern of negative feedback should not be ignored. Overall, the conversation highlights the need for a nuanced approach to interpreting professor ratings, focusing on the context of comments rather than just numerical scores.
e^(i Pi)+1=0
Messages
246
Reaction score
1
I'm taking my first two engineering courses in the fall, but I'm thinking I might hold off now until I transfer. I looked up my teachers on rateyourprofessor.com and they both have received pretty abysmal reviews. Is this maybe student's normal reactions to their first engineering courses, or is this atypical? I've found this site to jibe pretty well with my experiences in the past.

http://www.ratemyprofessors.com/ShowRatings.jsp?tid=416521&page=1

http://www.ratemyprofessors.com/ShowRatings.jsp?tid=354649&page=1
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Rate my professor is a horrible reference. At my university the absolute best mathematics professor has horrible ratemyprofessor scores. It's simply because he teaches difficult courses with difficult work. He is an absolutely brilliant teacher though.

If I were you, I would ask other people who have taken the course, and are actually interested in the material or at least moderately intelligent. Ask the tutors at your tutoring center (if you have one) about the professors. They hear about all of the professors for the subjects they tutor, if they have not had them directly
 
When I attended a small university, my best professors were the ones wit the worst ratings on ratemyprofessor.
 
I'll be completely honest with you: It is usually a dull person who blames his teacher after he failed. Otherwise, he'd have to admit he is dull.
 
In my experience (2nd year engi going to 3rd) RmP has been more right than wrong. I completely understand many of the complaints but I'm crazy and take the teacher anyway. Most of the teachers with a bad rating that I've had the displeasure of taking have been lacklustre, however, I like to self-learn so I'm ok with it.

BTW--2.4 is not that bad. I once took a teacher with a 1.2--he didn't speak a lick of English and made a sadistic dynamics midterm where a 40% (grade on the midterm) was an A+--23% was a PASS.
 
Rate my professor is good if the teacher has an enormously thick accent, especially for those of us with hearing impairments. Generally, don't go by the actual ratings, go by the comments. If it's "ohh this guy is SO HARD", then don't fret. If it's "Jesus, who can understand this guy?", then run - run away.
 
I just started looking at ratemyprof when signing up for this semester. My circuits teacher had about 5 comments along the lines of "Worst professor ever." I figured it's just a bunch of lazy kids complaining but I was wrong. He really is the worst professor I've ever had. Unorganized, unprepared, horrible lectures, he makes it seem like a questioning student is an idiot, etc. Also, it takes him about a month to give test grades back.

The other professors I checked out also had accurate comments. It's pretty easy to catch some angry kid posting because he failed but if the professor has a track record of bad comments then I would take that as a warning.
 
^^Exactly^^

I would never listen to a single comment but if there are 15+ "this guy is brutal" comments I would be careful.
 
Back
Top