Are These Two Reaction Mechanisms for the Same Reaction?

  • Thread starter Thread starter OmiChem
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Reaction
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around two proposed reaction mechanisms for the same chemical reaction involving OCl-, H2O, I-, and the formation of OI- and water. The first mechanism has a medium-speed initial step, while the second mechanism features a slow initial step. The key point is that both mechanisms yield the same net reaction, confirming they pertain to the same overall reaction. However, the mechanisms differ in their rate-determining steps, which affects their validity. The rate expression provided, Rate = k[I-], indicates that the concentration of I- influences the reaction rate. To determine which mechanism is correct, one must analyze the rate-determining steps in relation to the rate expression. Not all mechanisms that lead to the same products are valid; the correct mechanism must align with the observed rate law.
OmiChem
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
I'm given two reaction mechanisms, both are supposedly for the same reaction and I'm asked to prove it. The reaction mechanisms are:

#1

OCl- + H2O --> HOCl + OH- (medium speed)
HOCl + I- --> HOI + Cl- (slow)
HOI + OH- --> H2O + OI- (fast)

#2

OCl- + H2O --> HOCl + OH- (slow speed)
HOCl + I- --> ICl + OH- (medium)
ICl + 2OH- --> OI- + Cl- + H2O (fast)

I'm guessing that since the original reactants are the same for both and they both form OI- and water as a product, they are the same.. the only difference I can see is that the chlorine ion is separated in a different step, which causes a difference in the rate of that elementary reaction. Also, the rate expression for the final reaction: Rate = k[I-] SHOULD be right, but I'm not sure if it is.. I- seems to be the ion that affects the rate but I'm a little behind on my organic chem so I need some help...thx ahead of time
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
You are required to prove that they pertain to the same overall reaction ?

In both cases, find the net reaction by simply adding the parts. What do you get ?
 
Oh, sorry, i should of explained more.. there are three parts to the question.. the first is to show that both are for the same reaction, I should of known that, sorry slipped my mind totally to use the net equation... wow lol. Other than that, I am given the rate expression and asked questions about changes such as tripling the I- concentration and such, i do not need help with that. It then proceeds to ask me which mechanism is correct. This i don't understand. How do i figure out which of the mechanisms is correct...if both are for the same reaction, aren't they both correct?
 
No, they won't both be correct. I can make up a bogus mechanism for the same reaction, and it would definitely be wrong. You determine the correct mechanism by looking at the rate equation. According the the opening post, Rate = k[I-] is the given rate equation.

What do you know about rate determining steps ?
 

Thread 'Humidity of a saturated NaCl solution with anticaking additive'

I want to test a humidity sensor with one or more saturated salt solutions. The table salt that I have on hand contains one of two anticaking agents, calcium silicate or sodium aluminosilicate. Will the presence of either of these additives (or iodine for that matter) significantly affect the equilibrium humidity? I searched and all the how-to-do-it guides did not address this question. One research paper I found reported that at 1.5% w/w calcium silicate increased the deliquescent point by...
View full post »

Thread 'Why does having 8 valence electrons make an element inert?'

I was introduced to the Octet Rule recently and make me wonder, why does 8 valence electrons or a full p orbital always make an element inert? What is so special with a full p orbital? Like take Calcium for an example, its outer orbital is filled but its only the s orbital thats filled so its still reactive not so much as the Alkaline metals but still pretty reactive. Can someone explain it to me? Thanks!!
View full post »

Thread 'Resists for etching Aluminium with NaOH'

I'm trying to find a cheap DIY method to etch holes of various shapes through 0.3mm Aluminium sheet using 5-10% Sodium Hydroxide. The idea is to apply a resist to the Aluminium then selectively ablate it off using a diode laser cutter and then dissolve away the Aluminium using Sodium Hydroxide. By cheap I mean resists costing say £20 in small quantities. The Internet has suggested various resists to try including... Enamel paint (only survived seconds in the NaOH!) Acrylic paint (only...
View full post »

Similar threads

Electrodialysis with different anions
Replies
1
Views
1K
What are the potential products of the reaction between acetylene and HOCl?
Replies
6
Views
2K
Why are the Two SSA Equations the Same in a Catalytic Cycle?
Replies
7
Views
2K
Writing Reactions: Acid/Base Balanced Reactions
Replies
4
Views
2K
Redox Reaction in Dissolved Ammonium Chloride
Replies
5
Views
3K
Strong Acid Reactions: Explaining HCl + H2O → Cl- + H3O+
Replies
3
Views
5K
Would arrow pushing explain the mechanism of these oxide reactions?
Replies
1
Views
1K
NBS vs radical HBr in the bromination of olefins
Replies
2
Views
12K
What is the rate law for the Eigen-Wilkins reaction mechanism?
Replies
2
Views
5K
How Do You Propose a Reaction Mechanism for a Multi-Step Reaction?
Replies
10
Views
5K

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top