Solve Geom/Trigo Problem: Show BC=2h.tan2\theta

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mentallic
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a geometry problem involving a tower and angles of depression to points B and C. The solution shows that BC equals 2h.tan(2θ) by using trigonometric identities and relationships in a right triangle. Participants express concern about the complexity of the solution, suggesting there may be a simpler method. The conversation highlights the importance of recognizing relationships between angles and using them effectively in calculations. Ultimately, the participants seek a more straightforward approach to the problem without extensive algebraic manipulation.
Mentallic
Homework Helper
Messages
3,802
Reaction score
95

Homework Statement


D is the top of a tower h metres high. A is the foot of the tower. The angles of depression of the points B and C from D are 45+\theta and 45-\theta respectively. Show that BC=2h.tan2\theta

http://img43.imageshack.us/img43/9195/trigo.th.jpg

The Attempt at a Solution



\angle ADB=90-(45+\theta)=45-\theta

Therefore, tan(45-\theta)=\frac{AB}{h}

Then, AB=h.tan(45-\theta)

\angle CDA=90-(45-\theta)=45+\theta

Therefore, tan(45+\theta)=\frac{AB+CD}{h}

Then, AB=h.tan(45+\theta)-CD

So I equated h.tan(45-\theta)=h.tan(45+\theta)-CD

And finally, through expanding using the tangent sum formula and 'compressing' back into the double tangent formula, I resulted in BC=2h.tan2\theta


My problem is that this way to do it took far too long. There must be an easier way but I cannot seem to find it. I need your help :smile:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
Are B and D assumed to be in a straight line with A?
 
Yes. The diagram is simply a right-angled triangle with another line going from D to a point B on the opposite line of the triangle.

EDIT: Re-reading your question Hallsofivy, I think I may need to post a diagram to clear things up.
 
Bump. To re-iterate: I doubt such a question given to our class to answer would require over a page of algebraic manipulations, and this is why I'm thinking there is a much easier way to use that 2\theta in the diagram directly, and not obtain it through the tangent double angle formula.
 
If the angle of depression to B is 45+\theta, then the angle DB makes with DA is 90- (45+ \theta-)= 45-\theta and the angle DC makes with DA is 90- (45- \theta= 45+\theta. CA/h= tan(45+\theta) and BA/h= tan(45-\theta) so CB= CA- BA= h(tan(45+\theta)- tan(45-\theta)). Now use the identities for tan(a+ b) and tan(a-b).
 
Hi Mentallic! :smile:

(have a theta: θ :wink:)
Mentallic said:
… Then, AB=h.tan(45-\theta)

My problem is that this way to do it took far too long. There must be an easier way but I cannot seem to find it. I need your help :smile:

yeees :redface:

having got your AB = h.tan(45º - θ),

you never actually said AC = h.tan(45º + θ) …

which gives you the answer much quicker! :smile:
 
Oh that's much quicker! Thanks to both of you :smile:

Still curious though, can this problem be solved without the trig identities? Such as using the 2\theta angle and finding its tangent etc.?
 
Back
Top