Solve the Functions Problem: Are These Graphs the Same? | Algebra Help Needed

  • Thread starter neuro.akn
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Functions
In summary: Although it could be a typo and it's actually slope=1.5.Your graph looks like F(x) = 2x to meSee attachment. That's what I think the graph for second function would be but I would rather wait for someone else to confirm.
  • #1
neuro.akn
30
0

Homework Statement


Two students are arguing over the following equations. One student claims that the graphs are the same, the other student claims they are different. The equations are as follows:


Homework Equations


y = x - 1 and y = x^2 - 1 / x + 1 (x + 1 is the divisor)

The Attempt at a Solution


I believe the graphs are different, but an algebraic solution must be included. Please help solving this problem algebraically. Any help is greatly appreciated. Thank you.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Well, they are different. You'll have to simplify the 2nd function, but in doing so, an assumption has to be made. What is that assumption?
 
  • #3
Well, when the second equation is simplified: x - 1 is left over, correct? I'm not sure what exact assumption you are referring to.
 
  • #4
Don't simplify anything. Does a value for the second function exist if X = -1?

Simplifying a multidimensional equation to make it "easier" to solve as a linear one is not correct. However many dimensions an equation has, that many solutions you must also have. If you "simplify" to a lower dimension you will lose solutions and your entire solution would be incorrect.
 
  • #5
neuro.akn said:

Homework Statement


Two students are arguing over the following equations. One student claims that the graphs are the same, the other student claims they are different. The equations are as follows:


Homework Equations


y = x - 1 and y = x^2 - 1 / x + 1 (x + 1 is the divisor)

The Attempt at a Solution


I believe the graphs are different, but an algebraic solution must be included. Please help solving this problem algebraically. Any help is greatly appreciated. Thank you.

Never, never write what you wrote, which was
[tex] y = x^2 - \frac{1}{x} + 1[/tex]
when you mean
[tex] y = \frac{x^2 - 1}{x+1}.[/tex]
Use parentheses, like this: y = (x^2-1)/(x+1). It only takes an extra 1--2 seconds to type, and it makes everything clear and unambiguous.

Anyway, ask yourself: does the first form make sense for alll x? Does the second form make sense for all x? If not, what goes wront?
 
  • #6
Ray Vickson said:
Anyway, ask yourself: does the first form make sense for alll x? Does the second form make sense for all x? If not, what goes wront?

eumyang said:
Well, they are different. You'll have to simplify the 2nd function, but in doing so, an assumption has to be made. What is that assumption?

lendav_rott said:
Don't simplify anything. Does a value for the second function exist if X = -1?

Well you make me unsure what official doctrine is about whether f(x)g(x)/g(x) exists where g(x) = 0 .

But let me point out that that was not the question, the question was about graphs. Assuming every point satisfying y = the function has to be on a black line, are you able to show me graphs for these two functions, if there are two, which are different? :tongue2:
 
  • #7
I apologize for not using parentheses. It's my first time using this forum. I have solved the problem if I simplify the multidimensional equation, but I'm not sure how that is not correct. Thank you, everyone.
 
  • #8
I made a post earlier, but I didn't realize that I solved it for you. Be careful when you simplify, though. Revise the material that addresses continuous functions and the conditions. You said you solved the problem if you simplify, well are you sure you didn't divide by 0?
 
  • #9
What is your, or anyone's, answer?
 
  • #10
epenguin said:
What is your, or anyone's, answer?

I guess the graphs would be different. The second function is not defined at x=-1 so I think the graph would be a straight line (it reduces to linear after factorisation) with a discontinuity at x=-1 (shown by a small circle?).
 
  • #11
Pranav-Arora said:
I guess the graphs would be different. The second function is not defined at x=-1 so I think the graph would be a straight line (it reduces to linear after factorisation) with a discontinuity at x=-1 (shown by a small circle?).

I disagree, see #7.

But I indicate there how anyone can prove me wrong. :smile:
Graphically.
 
  • #12
epenguin said:
I disagree, see #7.

But I indicate there how anyone can prove me wrong. :smile:
Graphically.

See attachment. That's what I think the graph for second function would be but I would rather wait for someone else to confirm.
 

Attachments

  • graph.png
    graph.png
    3.9 KB · Views: 422
Last edited:
  • #13
This is a post that got deleted since it was considered as solving the problem. I hope it is alright to repost it now since people demand blood:
A function is continuous if 3 conditions are met. Since one sides assumes they are the same function it must also mean they are both continuous because the 1st one is.
F(x) = x-1
G(x) = (x^2-1)/(x+1)
1) A function f(x) has a specific value for any argument value, for example x=a. do they? Any argument value, so x = -1.
F(-1) = -2 OK
G(-1) = N/a, since division by 0 occurs Not OK

2)A function has a specific limit in case of x->a. When a = -1
lim x->-1 F(x) = -2
lim x->-1 G(x) = no limit, because reduction is only allowed if the factors =/= 0, in this case they are 0 therefore operation not permitted.

3)The most obvious one - The value of f(x) in case of x=a is equal to the limit in case of x->a
The condition is met for f(x) in case of x=-1 and x->-1
The condition is Not met for g(x) for the same argument value.

For whatever else argument value these conditions are met, because then you are allowed to reduce the factors as they are not 0, but there occurs a discontinuity for g(x) which makes these 2 functions Different.

#13 Your graph looks like F(x) = 2x to me
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #14
Pranav-Arora said:
See attachment. That's what I think the graph for second function would be but I would rather wait for someone else to confirm.

Elementary mistake there I think. Using the formula as written in #6 I think the slope should be 1 not 2. And also we should have the graph of the first condition for comparison.
 
Last edited:
  • #15
epenguin said:
Elementary mistake there I think. Using the formula as written in #6 I think the slope should be 1 not 2. And also we should have the graph of the first gundtion for comparison.

Woops. Fixed it.
 
  • #16
Does the graph of y = (x - 1) look different?
 
  • #17
Yes, it does not contain a discontinuity at x = -1.
 
  • #18
lendav_rott said:
Yes, it does not contain a discontinuity at x = -1.

And your graph does? I can't see a discontinuity on your graph either.
 
  • #20
After thinking about Riemann's theorem on removable singularities I get the feeling it's correc to state that they are the same functions or different, since Riemann doesn't say it's incorrect to imply a discontinuity, even though holomorphically extendable, makes the difference between our 2 functions. From hereon, I am a neutral party :D
 
  • #21
I have figured the problem out. The graphs are different, as x =/= -1. Thus, using g(x) = (x^2-1) / (x+1) there is a point discontinuity at x = -1. Thank you everyone! Much appreciated.
 
  • #22
I have solved the problem. The graphs are different because given g(x) = (x^2 - 1) / (x + 1) there is a point discontinuity, for x =/= - 1. Thank you, everyone! Much appreciated.
 
  • #23
neuro.akn said:
I have figured the problem out. The graphs are different, as x =/= -1. Thus, using g(x) = (x^2-1) / (x+1) there is a point discontinuity at x = -1. Thank you everyone! Much appreciated.

And I claim that's wrong! No graph can show you a "point discontinuity" like that.

(to cut lng stry shrt). And the one we have doesn't.
 

1. How can I determine if two graphs represent the same function?

To determine if two graphs represent the same function, you can use the vertical line test. This test involves drawing a vertical line on the graph. If the line passes through the graph at more than one point, then the graph does not represent a function. If the line only passes through one point, then the graph represents a function. You can also compare the x and y values of each graph to see if they are equivalent for the same input.

2. What is the difference between a function and a relation?

A function is a type of relation where each input (x-value) has exactly one output (y-value). In other words, for each x-value, there is only one y-value. A relation, on the other hand, can have multiple outputs for a single input. So while all functions are relations, not all relations are functions.

3. Can two different equations have the same graph?

Yes, two different equations can have the same graph. This is because there are infinitely many equations that can represent the same graph. For example, the equations y = x^2 and y = -x^2 + 4 have different forms, but they both graph a parabola.

4. How do you know if two graphs are identical?

If two graphs have the same shape, direction, and points, then they are identical. This means that for every input, the corresponding output is the same for both graphs. You can also use the vertical line test to confirm that the graphs are identical.

5. Can two different functions have the same graph?

Yes, two different functions can have the same graph. This is because the behavior of a function is not solely determined by its graph. The domain and range, as well as the equation or rule, also play a role in defining a function. Therefore, two different functions can have the same graph if they have different domains, ranges, or equations.

Similar threads

  • Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
754
  • Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
914
  • Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
474
  • Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
Replies
11
Views
501
  • Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
884
  • Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
Replies
32
Views
831
Back
Top