Solving Difficult Integral in Cosmology Lectures

  • Thread starter Thread starter Onamor
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Integral
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on evaluating the integral \(\int \frac{da}{\sqrt{\frac{H_{0}^{2}\Omega_{0}}{a}+l^{-2}}}\) using the substitution \(\frac{a}{l^{2}H^{2}_{0}\Omega_{0}}=\sin^{2}(\frac{u}{2})\). Participants highlight that the substitution may not correctly transform the integral, leading to difficulties in obtaining the correct answer. An alternative substitution involving hyperbolic sine is suggested for cases where the integral has a minus sign in front of \(l^{-2}\). Ultimately, the consensus is that the original substitution does not facilitate solving the integral effectively.
Onamor
Messages
76
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Hi, this situtation arises in my cosmology lectures, but its purely mathematical:

I need to evaluate the LHS of \int \frac{da}{\sqrt{\frac{H_{0}^{2}\Omega_{0}}{a}+l^{-2}}}=dx^{0}-dx^{0}_{*}
using the substitution \frac{a}{l^{2}H^{2}_{0}\Omega_{0}}=\sin^{2}(\frac{u}{2})

Homework Equations


The answer is only possible/needed in parametric form:
a=\frac{l^{2}H^{2}_{0}\Omega_{0}}{2}(1-\cos(u))
dx^{0}-dx^{0}_{*}=\frac{l^{3}H^{2}_{0}\Omega_{0}}{2}(u-\sin(u))

The Attempt at a Solution


So first I differentiate the substitution \frac{da}{du}\frac{1}{l^{2}H^{2}_{0}\Omega_{0}}=\sin(\frac{u}{2})\cos(\frac{u}{2}) .
Then some algebra with the LHS: \int \frac{da}{\sqrt{\frac{H_{0}^{2}\Omega_{0}}{a}+l^{-2}}}=l\int \frac{da}{\sqrt{\frac{l^{2}H_{0}^{2}\Omega_{0}}{a}+1}}=l\int \frac{da}{\sqrt{\frac{1}{\sin^{2}(\frac{u}{2})}+1}}
=l\int \frac{da \sin(\frac{u}{2})}{\sqrt{1+sin^{2}(\frac{u}{2})}}}=l^{3}H^{2}_{0}\Omega_{0}\int \frac{du \sin^{2}(\frac{u}{2}) \cos(\frac{u}{2})}{\sqrt{1+sin^{2}(\frac{u}{2})}}}
Where in the last line I have used the substition. Giving me a very difficult integral which doesn't give the right answer anyway (according to Mathematica).

Any help is greatly appreciated
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
The substitution you're using does not convert 1/\sqrt{H_0^2\Omega_0/a + l^2} into l/\sqrt{l^2H_0^2\Omega_0/a + 1}. Check that mathematical step.

In any case, are you sure that's the substitution you should be using? I would think it should be a little different.
 
AH! so sorry, I've misstyped the equation it should read
\int \frac{da}{\sqrt{\frac{H_{0}^{2}\Omega_{0}}{a}+l^{-2}}}=dx^{0}-dx^{0}_{*}
which is where my algabra comes from

So sorry, i will alter it in the OP now..

thank you very much for you're quick reply.
I've checked the substitution, and this is the form that my lecturer gives in his notes... but it did seem strange to me also.
 
A side note on the choice of substitution:
If we had a minus infront of the l^{-2}, so;
\int \frac{da}{\sqrt{\frac{H_{0}^{2}\Omega_{0}}{a}-l^{-2}}}=dx^{0}-dx^{0}_{*}
then I would be suggested the substitution
\frac{a}{l^{2}H^{2}_{0}\Omega_{0}}=\sinh^{2}(\frac{u}{2})
and this would give the parametric solutions
a=\frac{l^{2}H^{2}_{0}\Omega_{0}}{2}(\cosh(u)-1)
dx^{0}-dx^{0}_{*}=\frac{l^{3}H^{2}_{0}\Omega_{0}}{2}(\sinh(u)-u)
 
Actually, it'd make more sense to use the hyperbolic sine for the plus case (the one you have), and the trigonometric sine for the minus case.

Bottom line, I don't see how the substitution given in your original post helps you solve the integral you have.
 
Thread 'Help with Time-Independent Perturbation Theory "Good" States Proof'
(Disclaimer: this is not a HW question. I am self-studying, and this felt like the type of question I've seen in this forum. If there is somewhere better for me to share this doubt, please let me know and I'll transfer it right away.) I am currently reviewing Chapter 7 of Introduction to QM by Griffiths. I have been stuck for an hour or so trying to understand the last paragraph of this proof (pls check the attached file). It claims that we can express Ψ_{γ}(0) as a linear combination of...
Back
Top