Solving Gauss' Law for Electric Field Around Spherical Shell

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the electric field strength in the region between the inner and outer radii of a spherical shell with a uniform charge density and a point charge at its center. The user initially calculated the charge density as ρ = -6q/7πR^3 and derived the electric field using Gauss' Law, but found a discrepancy with the textbook's answer. Participants clarified the correct charge density and emphasized the importance of using pure LaTeX for formatting equations. There was also a request for step-by-step help on understanding charge density concepts. The conversation highlights the challenges faced by students in applying Gauss' Law and understanding charge density in electrostatics.
radiator0505
Messages
10
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


a spherical shell has an outer radius R and a inner radius R/2 and carries a total charge -q, distributed with uniform charge density. A point charge +q is at the centre of the sphere. Calculate the electric field strength for R/2<r<R

Homework Equations



Gauss' Law

The Attempt at a Solution



I figured out the charge density in the shell ρ = \frac{-6q}{7πR^3}, so the charge enclosed by a gaussian sphere is q(1-\frac{8r^3}{7R^3})

Then using gauss' law I get E = \frac{q}{4πε_0r^2}(1-\frac{8r^3}{7R^3})

But my book says E = \frac{q}{4πε_0r^2}\frac{8}{7}(1-\frac{r^3}{R^3})Also does anyone know why the latex things aren't working? I'm new to all this stuff.

Edit: cheers guys
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
radiator0505 said:
Also does anyone know why the latex things aren't working? I'm new to all this stuff.


Don't use the BB code tags like inside the LaTeX code. If you want to do superscripts in the LaTex math code, use ^ .
 
radiator0505 said:
Also does anyone know why the latex things aren't working? I'm new to all this stuff.
Could be that you're combining Latex with non-Latex stuff. Stick to pure Latex and it should work.
 
radiator0505 said:
I figured out the charge density in the shell ρ = \frac{-6q}{7πR^3},
Good.

so the charge enclosed by a gaussian sphere is q(1-\frac{8r^3}{7R^3})
Redo that one.

(FYI: I agree with the book's answer.)
 
how do you get
radiator0505 said:
ρ = −6q7πR3
 
jilia said:
how do you get
What's the definition of charge density?
 
Doc Al said:
What's the definition of charge density?
i don't really understand charge density. all i know is that it have 3 charge densities, volume, area, and linear.
i just learned this today and i get ρ = −6q/πR3 not ρ = −6q/7πR3.
can you help me solve this step by step?
 
jilia said:
i don't really understand charge density. all i know is that it have 3 charge densities, volume, area, and linear.
Here we are talking about ρ, which is a volume density.

jilia said:
i just learned this today and i get ρ = −6q/πR3 not ρ = −6q/7πR3.
can you help me solve this step by step?
Why don't you show how you arrived at your answer?
 
Back
Top