Solving Isotopic Symbols Problems: Ar-40 & Beyond

  • Thread starter Thread starter Meseria
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Symbols
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around confusion regarding isotopic symbols in an online chemistry course. The user is tasked with identifying isotopes based on given neutron counts but finds the instructions vague and lacking specific numbers. They initially guessed incorrectly and were surprised to find that the answer was Ar-40 without understanding how to derive it from the problem's wording. Other participants express similar frustrations, suggesting that the problem likely contains a typo or missing information, such as the number of protons or specific neutron counts. They speculate that the course's system may need debugging, as their own attempts yielded different isotopes, indicating a potential inconsistency in the questions. Overall, the consensus is that clearer instructions or additional context are necessary for students to accurately solve these isotopic problems.
Meseria
Messages
16
Reaction score
0
I am in an online chemistry course and its going well except for this particular type of problems. It states letters and tells me to write what isotope it is. Here goes...

Write isotopic symbols of the form X-A (e.g., C-13) for each of the following isotopes.

the a isotope with n(subscript a) neutrons. That's all it says. Nothing else. So i guessed trying like A-a but that was not it. I clicked show answer and it says it is Ar-40. How does one arrive at that? How does a isotope with n(sub a) neutrons = Ar-40?

Then it goes b isotope with n(sub b) neutrons, c with n(sub c), and d with n(sub d). I would like to know how this works. It feels like i am playing riddles.

There are other similar questions after this group but i think if somebody explains how you go from a isotope with n(sub a) neutrons to Ar-40 i will be able to figure out the rest for myself.

I could post an image of the questions if this doesn't make any sense.

Thank you.
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
I think someone forgot to insert the actual numbers into the problem. As it stands, the answer does not follow from the given information (unless a and na are defined somewhere).
 
I am posting a screen shot of the problem. So does this make any sense to anybody?
 

Attachments

  • Dibujo.jpg
    Dibujo.jpg
    19.5 KB · Views: 860
Is there an equality somewhere that indicates that na = 22?
 
IMHO system needs debugging :wink:
 
Meseria said:
I am posting a screen shot of the problem. So does this make any sense to anybody?

Yeah dude, I saw the picture. and I am doing mastering chemistry too as I googled explanations on why N sub a was an actual element. but apparently when I typed "Ar-40" mine was incorrect, for my (a) answer was "Ar-36". So, I guess by random, the isotopes are switched from time to time. and we're just going to have to forfeit the points. luckily, my instructor grades upon completion rather than percentage of correct answers, so hopefully yours does too.

So, I believed you asked, how they came to that conclusion. And my only conclusion is that there was a typo error on the website where somebody making the homework problems just forget to edit the "x" values (a & a sub n, etc...) before it was completed. That's my only guess.
 
When I first looked at this, I thought it would be something like A-(p + n (sub a)), but for that, you would need to know the number of protons (p) in A. I'm guessing someone forgot to give the values when inputting the problem, like everyone else said.
 
Back
Top