Solving Normal Distribution Homework: μ, σ, X, p

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on solving a normal distribution homework problem involving the calculation of mean (μ) and standard deviation (σ). The user calculated the mean as 40 and the standard deviation as approximately 5.48, but expected the probability for at least 40 to be 0.5000. However, the actual answer is 0.5364, highlighting a misunderstanding of the normal approximation. A key point raised is the importance of using continuity correction, suggesting that for a more accurate probability, the calculation should consider P{X ≥ 39.5} instead of P{X ≥ 40}. This adjustment leads to a more precise probability estimate of approximately 0.5364.
TyErd
Messages
297
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


I've attached the question.


Homework Equations


μ=np and σ=√(np(1-p))
Im using the normal distribution function on my calculator to avoid using z tables


The Attempt at a Solution


The mean I calculated it to be 160/4 = 40. standard deviation sqrt(160*1/4*3/4)=5.47723
The question is asking for at least 40(greater or equal to 40) that will choose biscuits but because this is a normal distribution it will be the same as greater than 40 so if I use an X value of 40 the probabilities should just equal 0.5000 right? however the answer is 0.5364
 

Attachments

  • 2222222222222222222.png
    2222222222222222222.png
    8.9 KB · Views: 505
Physics news on Phys.org
TyErd said:

Homework Statement


I've attached the question.

Homework Equations


μ=np and σ=√(np(1-p))
Im using the normal distribution function on my calculator to avoid using z tables

The Attempt at a Solution


The mean I calculated it to be 160/4 = 40. standard deviation sqrt(160*1/4*3/4)=5.47723
The question is asking for at least 40(greater or equal to 40) that will choose biscuits but because this is a normal distribution it will be the same as greater than 40 so if I use an X value of 40 the probabilities should just equal 0.5000 right? however the answer is 0.5364

You have not used the so-called "continuity correction" or "1/2 correction". If we approximate the binomial B(n,p) by the normal distribution when n is "large" but not really huge, it is better to apply the normal to points half-way between. In this case, it means the following. For the exact Binomial (on 0,1,2,...,160), the event {X ≥ 40} is the same event as {X ≥ 39.5}, because X can take only integer values. If you approximate P{X ≥ 40} by P{Normal ≥ 39.5} you will get a much more accurate answer. Here are the three results:
(1) Exact binomial P{X ≥ 40} = 0.53031930 ≈ 0.53
(2) Normal P{X ≥ 40} = 0.50
(3) Normal P{X ≥ 39.5} = 0.53636776 ≈ 0.54

RGV
 
Last edited:
Back
Top