Solving Physics Problem: Momentum of mK Affected by mL

  • Thread starter Thread starter BerkS
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Momentum Physics
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving two masses, mK and mL, where mL is dropped from a height of 18 meters and the momentum affecting mK is questioned. Participants debate whether the problem assumes standard Earth gravity, as the provided answer of 9 seems inconsistent with typical gravitational values. The concept of conservation of mechanical energy is suggested as a potential solution approach, although some express skepticism about solving it without explicit gravity values. Clarifications are sought on the problem's wording and context, emphasizing the need for complete information to accurately solve the problem. Ultimately, the consensus is that the problem may contain errors or insufficient data for a definitive solution.
BerkS
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Hey everybody,
there's one little problem I've been working on for hours now, I'm usually not that bad however I couldn't imagine how to solve this using the given Information:

1. Given Statement
mK=3kg
mL=2kg
There's no friction
-L is dropped without any speed, after falling 18 meters, what is the momentum(impuls? or sorry what ever it is lol..) affecting K in Newton.seconds

Sorry for the bad English, thanks for the help

https://docs.google.com/open?id=0B6PkUjlHR5ahaUtDQmZCWHFLR0U


Homework Equations


1/2at^2=x
mV=P
F.Δt=m.ΔV


The Answer is given as 9, though I couldn't formulate it into anything
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Why not try energy conservation?
 
Doc Al said:
Why not try energy conservation?

Is that possible without knowing the gravity of the system? If yes then how?
 
BerkS said:
Is that possible without knowing the gravity of the system?
What do you mean by "knowing the gravity" of the system? Isn't it on Earth with normal gravity?
If yes then how?
Mechanical energy is conserved. (Look up mechanical energy and conservation of energy.)
 
Doc Al said:
What do you mean by "knowing the gravity" of the system? Isn't it on Earth with normal gravity?

I'll try it again with conservation of energy, but no it's not necessarily on Earth.
 
BerkS said:
I'll try it again with conservation of energy, but no it's not necessarily on Earth.
If it's not on earth, I don't see how you can solve the problem. Not enough information.

Can you state the problem word for word as it was given? (What makes you think it's not on earth?)
 
Doc Al said:
If it's not on earth, I don't see how you can solve the problem. Not enough information.

Can you state the problem word for word as it was given? (What makes you think it's not on earth?)

In a system in which friction is unimportant, the bodies K and L are released. When body L has dropped 18 meters, what is the Impuls given K in kg.m/(s^2).s=N.s

I assume it's not on Earth because if it was the result couldn't be 9, and the book the question is from usually states the gravity either as 9.8 or (in some questions) 10.
 
Last edited:
BerkS said:
In a system in which friction is unimportant, the bodies K and L are released. When body L has dropped 18 meters, what is the Impuls given K in kg.m/(s^2).s=N.s
OK, clear enough.

I assume it's not on Earth because if it was the result couldn't be 9, and the book the question is from usually states the gravity either as 9.8 or (in some questions) 10.
I agree that the answer cannot be 9, but I suspect that's just an error in your problem statement or answer key. Unless they tell you otherwise, I would assume the set up is on Earth!

Show how you would solve the problem and then we can see if you're on the right track or not, regardless of the given answer.
 
Back
Top