Sound coming out of slide whistle

  • Thread starter Thread starter jai6638
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Slide Sound
AI Thread Summary
To play a note one octave higher on a slide whistle measuring 27 cm, the length should be halved to 13.5 cm. The initial confusion arose from miscalculating the conversion to meters, leading to an incorrect assumption about the required length. A higher frequency corresponds to a shorter wavelength, confirming that the whistle must indeed be shorter for higher notes. The discussion emphasizes the importance of using the correct units and understanding the relationship between frequency and wavelength. Ultimately, the correct length for the higher note is 13.5 cm.
jai6638
Messages
263
Reaction score
0
A slide whistle has a length of 27 cm. if you want ot play a note one octave higher the whistle should be how long?


Ans : 1/2 lambda = L

there Lambda = 2L
= (2)(27)
= 54 m

is that correct?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
That's a rather long whistle.
And the higher the frequency, the shorter the wavelength, so the whistle should be shorter if it's to produce a higher note.
 
so it would be 27/2 = 13.5 m?

thanks
 
13.5 m is also a tad long for a whistle. It'll look more like a digderidoo.
The length of the slide whistle was given in cm, not in meters.
I assume the whistle acts like a half open tube where waves have a node on the closed end and have a maximum at the open end, then the whistle should be half as long.
 
jai6638 said:
so it would be 27/2 = 13.5 m?

thanks

What, exactly, was the original length of the whistle? (Be Careful!)
 
my bad.. so the answer is (.27)(2) = .54m?
 
Except that you are going the wrong way again: a longer wave length gives a lower frequency.

Since the original length was given as "27 cm.", I would be inclined to give the answer as 13.5 cm.
 
Back
Top