Superconducting motor thought experiment/ questions

In summary, the conversation discusses the effects and properties of superconductors, particularly in relation to motors and generators. The participants question whether a superconducting motor would be more powerful and efficient, and how power consumption would be affected. They also discuss the concept of a homopolar motor and its potential use as an overunity device. Throughout the conversation, the role of zero resistance in the windings is a key factor in understanding the behavior of these machines.
  • #1
Robertphysics
16
4
I am sorry but this question I have described is a long one.
Ok so before I start a quick background , I have read and understand the Meissner effect of the superconductor expelling it’s magnetic field , also I understand that superconductor has zero resistance so a once induced or applied current can run forever in the superconductor unless it’s cooling fails or the current becomes so strong that the magnetic field collapses right?Now here is the interesting part , I read that superconductors apart from the magnetic field and zero resistance still obey Faraday’s law so if a current is already running in a superconducting coil then changing that current would still get a back EMF reaction and the magnetic field would oppose any change in current right ?So here are my questions. If we could cool down an ac induction motor so that it’s rotor armature and stator coils reach zero resistance , what would change ? I assume the motor would become more efficient and more powerful. But what would happen with its power consumption if it’s driving a fixed load? Normally I understand that as the motor drives a load its rotor is slowed down which creates more slip and less back EMF in the stator windings and allows more current to pass through them creating a stronger magnetic field which in turn creates more current in the rotor creating a stronger B field and driving the motor harder so that it can turn the load , but if there is zero resistance in the windings what does it mean , a larger current drawn still has zero resistance so what is then the mechanism for power consumption from the electrical load from which the motor is running ?
A similar question yet bit different. I know some stuff about homopolar motors/generators.
They are the only true DC power machines since all other DC motors use either a mechanical commutator to switch currents or semiconductor devices.
So what happens here , a superconducting homopolar motor is running basically a disc with an axial permanent magnet behind it and a piece of wire stationary with respect to the disc connected via brushes, let’s assume the brushes are lossless or have zero resistance as the disc. The whole system is in a superconducting state and represents a zero resistance DC current loop and experiences no EMF since there is no changing magnetic field present anywhere in this system and also no voltage as the current is DC and has zero resistance. What happens when a DC current is introduced in this loop? The disc starts rotating , but since there is zero resistance in the loop the current doesn’t dissipate so it just keeps flowing, now what happens when we introduce a load on the rotating shaft , does the current decreases in any way
This puzzles me because I cannot see any mechanism by which the current could be dissipated or influenced by attaching a load on the shaft which basically means an overunity device except for the power needed for cooling to keep the superconducting state.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
Robertphysics said:
but if there is zero resistance in the windings what does it mean , a larger current drawn still has zero resistance so what is then the mechanism for power consumption from the electrical load from which the motor is running ?
If the stator resistance is zero, the motor will be more efficient but if the rotor resistance is zero, motor wouldn't start at all.
 

1. What is a superconducting motor thought experiment?

A superconducting motor thought experiment is a hypothetical scenario that explores the potential uses and benefits of superconducting materials in the construction of electric motors. It involves imagining a motor that uses superconducting materials to achieve near-perfect efficiency and zero resistance.

2. How does a superconducting motor work?

A superconducting motor works by utilizing superconducting materials, which are materials that can conduct electricity with zero resistance when cooled to extremely low temperatures. This allows for the motor to operate with minimal energy loss and maximum efficiency.

3. What are the advantages of a superconducting motor?

The main advantage of a superconducting motor is its high efficiency. Since there is no resistance, the motor can operate with minimal energy loss, making it more cost-effective and environmentally friendly. Additionally, superconducting motors can also operate at higher speeds and produce less heat compared to traditional motors.

4. Are there any limitations to using superconducting motors?

One of the main limitations of superconducting motors is the need for extremely low temperatures to maintain their superconducting state. This requires specialized cooling systems, making them more expensive to produce and maintain. Additionally, the materials used in superconducting motors are currently limited and expensive, making them less practical for widespread use.

5. What are some potential applications of superconducting motors?

Superconducting motors have the potential to be used in various industries, such as transportation, energy production, and manufacturing. They could be used in electric vehicles to increase their range and efficiency, in power plants to generate electricity more efficiently, and in industrial machinery to reduce energy consumption and increase productivity.

Similar threads

  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
19
Views
455
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
3
Views
814
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
18
Views
2K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
9
Views
723
Replies
2
Views
958
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
7
Views
3K
Back
Top