Tension and compression forces on a femur bone

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
mishelhad
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Summary:: Hello all,
I need help with this question, ill attach the equations i managed to solve.
How do i continue from there?

Photo of a femur bone clamped at its upper end in a test rig, with a force arrow applied near the knee end and a labelled schematic of the experiment set-up below, with a load of 1,000 N.
Photo of a femur bone clamped at its upper end in a test rig, with a force arrow applied near the knee end and a labelled schematic of the experiment set-up below, with a load of 1,000 N.
Handwritten calculation on graph paper: stress = F/A and sigma = My/I boxed; F = 1,000 N, Do = 30 mm, Di = 16 mm; I = 3.14(30^4 - 16^4)/64 = 36,543.7 mm^4; A = pi(15^2 - 8^2) = 505.8 mm^2; sigma = 1000 N / 505.8 mm^2 = 1.97 N/mm^2; 1.97 = M·7.5 / 36,543.7; M = 9,598.8 boxed.
 
The stress should be expressed as N/m^2.

I have no idea how you determined the moment, but it certainly is not determined by the equation that you employed. It should be the force times the moment arm.
 
Looks like they found the axial stress and set it equal to the bending stress, which is incorrect. They should each be solved for by their respective equations.

I don't think there's anything inherently wrong with N*mm^-2, which is MPa, as long as the units are properly tracked. That said, the final answer doesn't even have any units with it.