I've never really liked most Thanksgiving food, especially turkey, but still wanted to make something that felt "traditional". So we looked up some recipes for medieval food. We made Poullaille Farcie (stuffed chicken) with meatballs, asparagus, and Frumenty (sweet cracked wheat). To drink, I made spiced cider with rum. And for dessert, poached pears.
Poullaille Farcie:
Whole chicken
Savory
Saffron
Onions
Carrots
Celery
Parsnips
Butter
Stuffing (below)
Chicken was stuffed, coated with herbs, and roasted, basted frequently with butter. Veggies were put in the bottom of the roasting pan, to absorb drippings and caramelize. They were made into their own side dish at the end by deglazing with Vermouth and reducing.
Stuffing:
Ground beef
Shredded chicken thighs
Onions
Beef broth
Savory
Cinnamon
Cloves
Saffron
Fennel bulb
Cooked chestnuts (they come pre-cooked in a jar!)
Eggs
Bread crumbs
Chicken thighs and beef were cooked ahead of time the night before, with beef stock, savory, cinnamon and cloves (i.e., chicken was cooked in stock and spices and then shredded after it cooled). Then excess liquid was reserved, and diced fennel bulb, chestnuts, egg, and breadcrumbs were added to give the right consistency. After stuffing the chicken, remaining stuffing was formed into meat balls, placed on a cookie sheet, and saffron sprinkled on top.
You can roast your own chestnuts if you like. We didn't really have that kind of time.
Asparagus:
No complicated ingredient list here, just asparagus. We chopped off the bottom inch or so, and peeled the lower half so as to get rid of the unwanted fibrous part. It's not really asparagus season, so all that was at the store was pretty thick. This is the last dish we cooked, because it is the most time-sensitive. Bring a large pot of salted water to a rolling boil. Then drop the asparagus in (I covered the pot also, but I have glass lids so I can see what's going on). Within about 5 minutes, it will turn a much brighter shade of green, and that's when it's done. Poke it with a fork maybe to test tenderness.
Frumenty:
Bulgur wheat
Cooked chestnuts
Dried cranberries
Cinnamon
Cloves
Fennel stalks
Beef stock (2:1 ratio to wheat)
Milk and/or cream
Simple enough. Here we used the beef stock that we had reserved from the stuffing, above, plus more fresh beef stock to bring it up to the 2:1 ratio. Put in all ingredients except milk, laying the fennel stalks on top (they will be removed later). Simmer for 20 minutes or so until it fluffs up. Remove fennel stalks. Then add milk and cook for a brief period more on lower heat (don't let the milk boil). I added only a token amount of milk...I think the dish is supposed to be creamier. It still tasted great.
Spiced cider:
Apple cider
Cinnamon sticks
Whole cloves
Fresh ginger
Allspice
Nutmeg
Juniper berries
Red pepper
Dark rum
For 1/2 gallon of apple cider (standard size of most juice bottles in the US), I put in 2-3 cinnamon sticks, 2/3 teaspoon cloves, 2/3 teaspoon allspice, 2/3 teaspoon juniper berries, about 1.5 inches of sliced ginger, and dashes of the rest. You don't need to peel the ginger, just slice it into moderately thin slices. Put everything except the rum into a pot and simmer it for 1/2 an hour. To serve, put a shot of rum in a mug, then pour cider through a strainer to fill.
Poached Pears:
Pears
Wine
Very easy, and it can cook while you're eating dinner. I sliced the pears into quarters and cut out the cores. You can peel them if you like. Then simmer them in wine for 1/2 an hour or so. The precise timing is not important. Use whatever kind of wine you like...I think a red wine makes them turn out beautiful, as the pears will absorb the color. We used a cheap Beaujolais, since they're on sale everywhere around Thanksgiving. By the time they're done, there will be no alcohol left in the wine, and the pears will sweeten it. If it's not sweet enough, I guess you can add honey or something, but I thought it was great as-is.