The limit Sin[ Sin[x] ] / x as x->0

suffian

I encountered this problem in a set of limit problems:

Limit[ Sin[ Sin[x] ] / x , x-> 0 ]

According to what my book says, if the interior function in the sine approaches zero and the denominator also approaches zero, then the limit is 1; which, as I verified, is the answer. But is there a way to solve this limit by analytic means by using the simple limit rules combined with the basic trig limits (i.e. not L'Hopital's Rule)?

Related Introductory Physics Homework Help News on Phys.org

bogdan

lim sin(sinx)/x=(lim sin(sinx)/sinx)*(lim sinx/x) (1)
lim sin(sinx)/sinx=lim sint/t, where t=sinx; x->0;t->0;
lim sint/t=1;lim sinx/x=1;
From (1) we obtain that the value of the limit is 1;
No L'Hospital...

Tom Mattson

Staff Emeritus
Gold Member
Very clever, bogdan!

Of course, you wouldn't know that lim sin(x)/x=1 without implicitly using L'Hopital, but you don't lose any points for that. suffian

thanks! i was getting used to multiplying by constants, but that's pretty ingenious.

bogdan

Look, no L'Hospital :
lim (sin(0+x)-sin0)/x=cos 0;x->0;(the derivitive..."derivate" in 0...bad english...);
lim (sin(0+x)-sin0)/x=lim sinx/x=cos 0=1; unfortunately calculating the "derivate" of sin we have to use
lim sinx/x=1...but...using the fact that sin is derivable on R (it's "derivate" it's finite everywere...and it exists) and the fact that sin(-x)=-sinx (it is "antisimmetric") then we obtrain that the left derivate of sin in 0 is equal to the right derivate...and because the function is "antisimetric" the derivate in 0 must be 1...isn't it right ?

Last edited:

bogdan

or...
in a vecinity of 0 we have :
sinx<x<tgx;(using some drawing...triangle areas...)
1<x/sinx<1/cosx;
jumping to limit we obtain:
lim 1<=lim x/sinx<=lim 1/cosx;x->0
1<=lim x/sinx<=1;=>lim x/sinx=1, from where lim sinx/x=1...
Again no L'Hospital...

petitbear

Cute. ottjes

for very small values of x sin[x] becomes almost x
so lim x->o sin[x]/x becomes x/x = 1

find this an easier way :)

ottjes

do what i said above twice, forgot you asked sin[sin[x]]

bogdan

almost ?
okay...but that has to be proven mathematically...precisely...
you can say that sinx=sqrt(1-cosx) for small values...but it's not correct...

ottjes

when you take the limit it is correct
but don't want to prove that mathematically :)

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving