The resistance of a wire without a voltage bias

AI Thread Summary
When a voltage bias is applied to a wire, the resistance causes electrons to collide with atoms, generating heat. Without a bias, electrons still move rapidly, but their collisions do not significantly warm the wire, similar to molecules in still air not warming themselves. The discussion references a physics text that notes the drift speeds of electrons are much smaller than their random thermal motion speeds. In equilibrium, thermal energy is conserved within the system if no energy is transferred in or out. The conversation emphasizes understanding the nature of thermal energy and its conservation in a closed system.
hokhani
Messages
561
Reaction score
18
When a bias is applied to a wire, due to the resistance of a wire, the electrons colliding with the atoms make the wire warmer. However, we know that without any bias the electrons also move with very large velocity (of the order 10^5 m/s). How about the collision of these rapid electrons with atoms? Do these collisions warm the wire or not?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
hokhani said:
However, we know that without any bias the electrons also move with very large velocity (of the order 10^5 m/s).
where did you read that ?
 
  • Like
Likes sophiecentaur
hokhani said:
When a bias is applied to a wire, due to the resistance of a wire, the electrons colliding with the atoms make the wire warmer. However, we know that without any bias the electrons also move with very large velocity (of the order 10^5 m/s). How about the collision of these rapid electrons with atoms? Do these collisions warm the wire or not?

With a bit of thought, you can answer your own question. Free electrons and atoms in a metal can be analogous to molecules in a gas. The molecules move and they collide. If you have a box of still air, does it warm itself? If not, why not? Where does the energy to move the molecules come from? Where does it go to?
 
  • Like
Likes Asymptotic, hokhani and sophiecentaur
davenn said:
where did you read that ?
Please see Physics(2) (Electricity & Magnetism), Resnick, Halliday, Krane, Volume Three, Fifth edition, page 665, the left column.
The sentence is: "The drift speeds of electrons in typical materials are very small compared with the speed of the random thermal motions of electrons (typically 10^6 m/s)"
 
anorlunda said:
still
Thanks. Do you believe that in the equilibrium conditions, the thermal energy is preserved in the system?
 
hokhani said:
Thanks. Do you believe that in the equilibrium conditions, the thermal energy is preserved in the system?

It is just like any other thermal system if no energy is transferred in or out, the internal energy is conserved.

I said still only to exclude things like a vertex in the air.

Do you understand now? Your original question was asking if thermal energy creates thermal energy.
 
anorlunda said:
Do you understand now? Your original question was asking if thermal energy creates thermal energy.
Right, Many thanks.
 
Back
Top