Electrons acceleration in a wire

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the behavior of electrons in a wire, particularly focusing on their acceleration and the implications for current flow in circuits. Participants explore theoretical scenarios involving zero resistance and the effects of electric fields on electron motion, as well as the relationship between acceleration and current in conductive materials.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants propose that in a hypothetical scenario with zero resistance and no atomic collisions, the forces acting on electrons (Fc1 and Fc2) would not be constant, leading to variable acceleration at different points in the wire.
  • Others argue that in a real conductive material, the presence of atomic collisions would affect electron acceleration, suggesting that the electric field acceleration gained by electrons is not constant throughout the wire.
  • A participant notes that while electrons in a conductor move randomly, applying a voltage results in a net current due to a slight preference for one direction, which contributes to the small drift velocity observed.
  • Another participant asserts that in a vacuum, the electric field is not uniform, and thus the sum force on electrons would also not be constant, contrasting this with the behavior in Ohmic materials where the electric field is uniform for a constant current.
  • There is a discussion about whether current remains constant in Ohmic materials for a specific voltage, with some participants affirming this as a defining characteristic of such materials.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the nature of electron acceleration in conductive materials and the implications for current flow. While some agree on the uniformity of the electric field in Ohmic materials, others challenge the assumptions about acceleration and current consistency, indicating that the discussion remains unresolved.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include assumptions about ideal conditions (zero resistance, no atomic collisions) versus real-world scenarios in conductive materials. The discussion also highlights the complexity of electron behavior at both microscopic and macroscopic levels, with unresolved mathematical steps regarding the relationship between acceleration and current.

aeacus
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
I have some questions about electrons flow.
1)Lets say we have a simple circuit with a metal wire and a battery supplier.Firstly if we can imagine an electrons flow in a conductive material like metal but with zero resistance and no atoms for the electrons to collide , the Fc1 force from the negative pole which repels electrons and the Fc2 of the positive pole that attracts them are both non constant and distance depended forces.So,Fsum=Fc1+Fc2.Ι know that electrons in this case would do an accelerative motion , but is Fsum as a sum force constant and thus electrons acceleration same at each point in this case or they do accelerate till the end but with bigger and smaller accelerations at each point?
I put that this way in order to understand if in a metal wire after each collision with atoms the electric field acceleration gained by an electron at different points throughout the wire is different or is constant.
2)The second question is depended on the answer of the first.According to my thinking electrons would do an accelerative motion throughout a metal wire (let's say an 1 meter wire example) but the acceleration would change prices at each point as it moves.So,how is it possible if the net accelerations are different at each point throughout the wire in a series circuit the current to be the same at each point? Different accelerations would accumulate in every wire point different amounts of electrons.If we suppose net accelerations change either increase or decrease, net velocity will continuesly getting higher so current would getting higher as electrons move further and further.I am not speaking for drift velocity just the net velocity(It is very different).So distribution would change very slightly.So,how come current is the same in every point?


Thanks in advance for the try and your time but please i don't want an answer with just a link to a physics law or a mathematical formula.I am student in university and i know the basics.I would just like a descriptive and serious answer.The meaning.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
aeacus said:
I have some questions about electrons flow.
1)Lets say we have a simple circuit with a metal wire and a battery supplier.Firstly if we can imagine an electrons flow in a conductive material like metal but with zero resistance and no atoms for the electrons to collide , the Fc1 force from the negative pole which repels electrons and the Fc2 of the positive pole that attracts them are both non constant and distance depended forces.So,Fsum=Fc1+Fc2.Ι know that electrons in this case would do an accelerative motion , but is Fsum as a sum force constant and thus electrons acceleration same at each point in this case or they do accelerate till the end but with bigger and smaller accelerations at each point?
I put that this way in order to understand if in a metal wire after each collision with atoms the electric field acceleration gained by an electron at different points throughout the wire is different or is constant.
2)The second question is depended on the answer of the first.According to my thinking electrons would do an accelerative motion throughout a metal wire (let's say an 1 meter wire example) but the acceleration would change prices at each point as it moves.So,how is it possible if the net accelerations are different at each point throughout the wire in a series circuit the current to be the same at each point? Different accelerations would accumulate in every wire point different amounts of electrons.If we suppose net accelerations change either increase or decrease, net velocity will continuesly getting higher so current would getting higher as electrons move further and further.I am not speaking for drift velocity just the net velocity(It is very different).So distribution would change very slightly.So,how come current is the same in every point?


Thanks in advance for the try and your time but please i don't want an answer with just a link to a physics law or a mathematical formula.I am student in university and i know the basics.I would just like a descriptive and serious answer.The meaning.
If there is no resistance, such as in a vacuum tube or cathode ray tube, the electrons accelerate from - to +.

In a circuit with resistive loads in series, the potential difference across those loads is distributed in proportion to the resistance. The end result is a steady state flow of current with the forces on the electrons at each point being just enough so that, on average, the charges move through the circuit at a constant rate. At the molecular level there are electrons slamming into atoms and picking up speed and losing speed all the time, but at the macroscopic level, Ohm's law applies.

AM
 
I'd like to point out that electrons in a conductor move in random directions. When no voltage is applied these random motions equal out to zero net current in either direction of the circuit. But when you apply a voltage this is no longer the case. The directions are still random, but when you add up all the directions there is a small preference for one direction, leading to current flow. This is why the drift velocity is so small in conductors. The current isn't composed of electrons moving in solely one direction, but instead is composed of a large number of electrons moving randomly throughout the conductor with a small preference for the direction of current flow.
 
aeacus said:
I have some questions about electrons flow.
1)Lets say we have a simple circuit with a metal wire and a battery supplier.Firstly if we can imagine an electrons flow in a conductive material like metal but with zero resistance and no atoms for the electrons to collide
This is not metal, this is vacuum.

aeacus said:
is Fsum as a sum force constant and thus electrons acceleration same at each point in this case or they do accelerate till the end but with bigger and smaller accelerations at each point?
In vacuum Fsum would not be constant. You can calculate or measure the E field and find that it is not constant.

aeacus said:
I put that this way in order to understand if in a metal wire after each collision with atoms the electric field acceleration gained by an electron at different points throughout the wire is different or is constant.
What you describe above will not help in understanding the behavior in a metal, just in vacuum.

aeacus said:
2)The second question is depended on the answer of the first.According to my thinking electrons would do an accelerative motion throughout a metal wire (let's say an 1 meter wire example) but the acceleration would change prices at each point as it moves.So,how is it possible if the net accelerations are different at each point throughout the wire in a series circuit the current to be the same at each point?
It is not possible. Therefore the net accelerations are not different.

aeacus said:
Different accelerations would accumulate in every wire point different amounts of electrons.If we suppose net accelerations change either increase or decrease, net velocity will continuesly getting higher so current would getting higher as electrons move further and further.I am not speaking for drift velocity just the net velocity(It is very different).So distribution would change very slightly.So,how come current is the same in every point?
Because the E field is uniform inside a wire with a uniform current, due to Ohm's law. This is the key difference. In the vacuum the E-field is not uniform, it is determined by Coulomb's law. In an Ohmic material the E-field depends on the current, it is uniform for a constant current.
 
Thank you all for yours answers.Dalespam your answer especially helped me very much.Let me ask you something though,is current always constant in an Ohmic material for a specific price of voltage?
 
Yes, that is essentially the defining characteristic of Ohmic materials.
 
DaleSpam said:
In an Ohmic material the E-field depends on the current, it is uniform for a constant current.

More specifically, in an Ohmic material with uniform resistivity ##\rho## and conductivity ##\sigma = 1/\rho##, ##\vec E## is uniform if the current density ##\vec J## is uniform:

$$\vec J = \sigma \vec E$$
 
The discussion above, with moving electrons, colliding with one another and atoms, having particular positions, velocities and accelerations, is a classical model of conductivity. We know now that it is seriously wrong. Conductivity in metals is a quantum phenomenon and can only be fully explained as such.
 

Similar threads

Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 28 ·
Replies
28
Views
5K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
9K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
4K
Replies
5
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
9K