1. Limited time only! Sign up for a free 30min personal tutor trial with Chegg Tutors
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Homework Help: The Same Integral Two Different Answers

  1. Jun 10, 2007 #1
    The Same Integral... Two Different Answers!!!

    1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data

    [tex] \int \frac{\tan x}{\cos^5 x} \,dx [/tex]

    3. The attempt at a solution

    Solution 1
    [tex] \int \frac{\tan x}{\cos^5 x} \,dx = \int \frac{\sin x}{\cos^6 x} [/tex]

    [tex]u = \cos x \,\,\,\, du = -\sin x \,dx [/tex]

    [tex]= -\int u^-^5 \,du = \frac{1}{4 u^4} + C [/tex]

    Answer 1: [tex] \frac{1}{4 \cos^4 x} + C [/tex]

    Solution 2

    [tex] \int \frac{\tan x}{\cos^5 x} \,dx = \int \tan x \sec^4 x \,dx = \int \tan x (1 + \tan^2 x) \sec^2 x \,dx [/tex]

    [tex]u = \tan x \,\,\,\, du = \sec^2 x \,dx [/tex]

    [tex] = \int \(u + u^3) \,du = \frac{1}{2} u^2 + \frac{1}{4} u^4 + C [/tex]

    Answer 2: [tex] \frac{1}{2} \tan^2 x + \frac{1}{4} \tan^4^ x + C[/tex]

    Wich one is right and why?
    Last edited: Jun 10, 2007
  2. jcsd
  3. Jun 10, 2007 #2
    In the first step of your second solution, you should have [tex]\sec^5{x}[/tex], not [tex]\sec^4{x}[/tex]. You're also off by a power in your first solution. Close, though.

    P.S.: Check your answers by taking derivatives and see if you arrive back at the integrand.
  4. Jun 10, 2007 #3


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    In the first attempt you should have [tex] -\int u^-^6 \,du [/tex]

    And similarly in the second attempt you have replaced [tex]\frac{1}{cos^5(x)} [/tex] with sec to the power 4 which is not correct.
  5. Jun 10, 2007 #4
    I will tell you that neither of the answers are right. You find where the erroneous step is.(It's quite simple, really)
    [EDIT]Hmm...never mind.

    A further simplification of the second method is to write down the integral as
    [tex] \int \frac{\tan x}{\cos^5 x} \,dx = \int \tan x \sec^5 x \,dx = \int \tan x \sec x \sec^4 x \,dx [/tex]
  6. Jun 10, 2007 #5

    Gib Z

    User Avatar
    Homework Helper

    Whenever you seem to get two solutions, differentiate both of them. If they both arrive back at the integrand, then try and see why the 2 solutions have a difference of a constant, thats what the +C's there for = ]
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook