Topology or logic or other start point?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the challenges faced when preparing for advanced math courses, specifically topology and math logic, due to difficulties with proofs. The individual has dropped these courses and seeks advice on the order of study for better preparation. There is a consensus that taking an introductory proof course is crucial for success in upper division courses, but the individual is unable to enroll in one due to their academic standing. Suggestions for self-preparation include studying proof books and drawing on intuition from related subjects, such as Visual Complex Analysis and electricity and magnetism, which can enhance understanding of proofs. The order of studying topology or math logic is deemed less critical, with emphasis placed on strengthening proof skills overall.
trap101
Messages
339
Reaction score
0
So i just recently had to drop two math courses, topology, math logic, because my math maturity wasn't up to the level needed to excel in them. I intend on taking them again, but not without first more preparation which leads to my question. Which order would i benefit more from in preparing for the courses? Topology first and then math logic? Or math logic first and then topology?

The reason is that proofs tend to be my major weakness and it is coming to haunt me in these more advanced courses. Anyother suggestions would also be appreciated

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Have you taken an intro to proof course? The rest of your upper division courses will rely on that foundational course (unless you are focusing on numerical applied math.)
 
The most my school offered when i took the courses was "concepts in abstract math" so there was no direct intro to proofs course, of course the school has now realized their mistake and created the course, but it is a first year course and i don't think i am eligible for it anymore considering i am in 3rd year. So it appears i will have to self prepare. Suggestions of any good proof books?
 
I don't see any particular advantage to doing one or the other first. My own success with proofs, especially in something like topology, I attribute to reading Visual Complex Analysis and studying subjects like electricity and magnetism that boosted my intuition. In a subject like topology, my thought process was usually a matter of translating my intuition into a logical proof. Proof books may help, too, but they may not be the whole story.
 
TL;DR Summary: What topics to cover to safely say I know arithmetic ? I am learning arithmetic from Indian NCERT textbook. Currently I have finished addition ,substraction of 2 digit numbers and divisions, multiplication of 1 digit numbers. I am moving pretty slowly. Can someone tell me what topics to cover first to build a framework and then go on in detail. I want to learn fast. It has taken me a year now learning arithmetic. I want to speed up. Thanks for the help in advance. (I also...
Hi community My aim is to get into research about atoms, specifically, I want to do experimental research that explores questions like: 1. Why do Gallium/Mercury have low melting points 2. Why are there so many exceptions and inconsistencies when it comes to explaining molecular structures / reaction mechanisms in inorganic and organic chemistry 3. Experimental research about fundamental Quantum Mechanics, such as the one being followed by Hiroshima university that proved that observing...
guys i am currently studying in computer science engineering [1st yr]. i was intrested in physics when i was in high school. due to some circumstances i chose computer science engineering degree. so i want to incoporate computer science engineering with physics and i came across computational physics. i am intrested studying it but i dont know where to start. can you guys reccomend me some yt channels or some free courses or some other way to learn the computational physics.

Similar threads

Back
Top