Trig Identities Applications Question

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving the equation 1/2(sin3x + sinx) = sin2x, with participants pointing out errors in the original approach. Key mistakes include misapplying trigonometric identities and incorrectly simplifying terms. The correct expression for sin3x + sinx should utilize product-to-sum formulas, leading to a more accurate formulation. Participants suggest revisiting the fundamental trigonometric identities and provide resources for clarification. Ultimately, the resolution requires careful application of these identities to derive the correct solutions for x.
Auburn
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Hello! I've been tackling the question 'Express sin3x+sinx as a product and hence solve 1/2(sin3x+sinx)=sin2x ; x∈R' but I'm stumped - I'm not sure whether I've even approached it correctly. This is what I did:

sin(3x+x)=sin3x.cosx+sinx.cos3x

inserting this into the second equation,
1/2(sin3x.cosx+sinx.cos3x)=2sinx.cosx

Moving cosx over
4sinx=sin3x+3sinx

sinx=sin3x

sin(2x+x)-sinx=0

sin2xcosx+cos2x.sinx-sinx=0

2sinxcos^2x+(cos^2 x - sin^2 x) sinx - sinx = 0

2sinxcos^2 x + cos^2xsinx - sin^3 x -sinx=0

sinx(2cos^2 x + cos^2 x - sin^2 x - 1) = 0

sinx(3cos^2x - sin^2x -1) =0

BRACKETS:

3cos^2x - sin^2x - 1 = 0

3cos^2x - (1- cos^2x) - 1 = 0

3cos^2x - 1 + cos^2x - 1 = 0

4cos^2x - 2 = 0

cos^2x = 1/2
and
sinx = 0

But at this point I'm stumped. The answer says x = n∏/2 , and I would've gone about the second equation by doing:
cosx = √(1/2)
x = α = cos^-1(√(1/2)) but this is obviously wrong... :S Argh, how am I supposed to get that answer?

Thanks in advance.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
1. Is the equation 1/2(sin3x + sinx) =sin2x ie do you have the 2 and 1 the wrong way round in the first line of your question?

2. sin(3x) + sin(x) is not the same as sin(3x+x)

This page might help you.
http://www.sosmath.com/trig/prodform/prodform.html
 
jing2178 said:
1. Is the equation 1/2(sin3x + sinx) =sin2x ie do you have the 2 and 1 the wrong way round in the first line of your question?

2. sin(3x) + sin(x) is not the same as sin(3x+x)

This page might help you.
http://www.sosmath.com/trig/prodform/prodform.html

Ah, yes it is, sorry. And thanks, I'll see what else I can do.
 
My working now:
sin3x+sinx = 2sin(3x+x/2)cos(3x+x/2)=0,

2sin2x.cos2x=0

adding into parenthesis
1/2(2sin2x.cos2x)=sin2x

2sin2x.cos2x=2sin2x

2sin2x.cos2x - 2sin2x=0

2sin2x(cos2x-1)=0

2sin2x=0, cos2x=0

But using the general equation formula for cos2x=0 gives me x=∏n, when the answer should be x=∏n/2? 2sin2x isn't even close.

I apologise for my high school level ignorance in advance!
 
Auburn said:
My working now:
sin3x+sinx = 2sin(3x+x/2)cos(3x+x/2)=0,

It looks like you made a mistake in the cosine part, look at the formula again. Also, why did you set the right side equal to zero? It looks like you made some mistakes further down, but you need to restart from an earlier point anyway.

1/2(2sin2x.cos2x)=sin2x

does not become

2sin2x.cos2x=2sin2x

The 1/2 and the 2 merely cancel.
 
Auburn said:
My working now:
sin3x+sinx = 2sin(3x+x/2)cos(3x+x/2)=0,

Note that 3x+x/2 = 7x/2 not 2x what you should write is (3x +x)/2

sin3x+sinx=2sin((3x+x)/2)cos(...) I have left the cos blank as e^(i Pi)+1=0 said you need to check the formula to obtain the correct expression.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top