Uncertainty principle leads to superlumina ?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on reconciling the uncertainty principle with the impossibility of superluminal speeds. It highlights that the uncertainty principle indicates a relationship between momentum and position, but does not imply that momentum can exceed the speed of light. The relativistic momentum equation shows that as velocity approaches the speed of light, momentum increases without bound, preventing any particle from surpassing light speed. The key takeaway is that while uncertainty allows for a range of momentum values, relativistic effects ensure that velocities remain below light speed. Thus, the principles of quantum mechanics and relativity coexist without contradiction.
for_Higgs
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
According to the uncertainty principle Δp*Δx≥h/2pi,
now suppose we measure a particle in a very tiny area(if x is tiny enough),
s.t. Δp ≥ h/(2xpi) ≥ mc then v > c.
But in fact, the velocity can not be faster than light.
So how can we compromise these two statement?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Are you perhaps thinking p = mv? The relativistic momentum is
$$p = \frac{mv}{\sqrt{1 - v^2/c^2}}$$
in which v < c always.
 
for_Higgs said:
According to the uncertainty principle Δp*Δx≥h/2pi,
now suppose we measure a particle in a very tiny area(if x is tiny enough),
s.t. Δp ≥ h/(2xpi) ≥ mc then v > c.
But in fact, the velocity can not be faster than light.
So how can we compromise these two statement?

Hi for_Higgs, welcome to PF!

First, the equation gives you the uncertainty in the momentum, not the value of the momentum.

Second, for velocities close to the speed of light, the change in mass due to velocity has to be accounted for. You have to use the relativistic momentum, such that ##p \rightarrow \infty## is the same as ##v \rightarrow c##, so the particle never exceeds the speed of light. [Edit: jtbell beat me to it]
 
Back
Top