Schools What Are the Latest Updates on 2016 Math REU Acceptances?

  • Thread starter Thread starter n-dimen
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    2016 Reu Summer
AI Thread Summary
Participants in the 2016 Math REU discussion are seeking updates on acceptance notifications from various programs, with some already reporting acceptances, such as UCSB and SMALL. Emory's participant list suggests they have completed their selections, while other programs like WADE and West Georgia are still in the decision-making process. There is ongoing debate about the significance of shortlists for programs like SMALL, with some participants unsure if they are required for acceptance. Several users are weighing the prestige of programs against funding opportunities, especially concerning Cornell's recent decision to cut funding. Overall, the competitive nature of REUs is highlighted, with many applicants anxiously awaiting responses from their chosen programs.
n-dimen
Messages
22
Reaction score
6
Going off last years thread, 2016 math reu acceptances (or general discussion)

Has anyone heard back yet?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Haven't heard anything yet. It seems Emory's participants have all been chosen because they're listed on the site, but I'm guessing it's the usual crop of MIT / Harvard and Emory kids.

Based on last year's info I'm guessing some first-round acceptance stuff will go out pretty soon, like within the next week or two?
 
Judging by last year's thread, we should be hearing back from SMALL and a few other programs right about now. Has anyone heard anything this far this week?
 
Acceptances have been sent out for SMALL already.
 
  • Like
Likes WhatIsCohomology
Okay, thanks for the reply. Does anyone have any news about Potsdam or TAMU or any other programs?
 
Have all SMALL projects been filled?

I know WADE is still interviewing.
 
I emailed them and they said they're not quite done with the process but that they're pretty sure I didn't get it, meaning that they're probably still filling up, but almost done.
 
For SMALL, do you always have to make it to the shortlist to get in? Or is it specific to some groups like the Number Theory one.
 
Shortlists? How long are those? From the name (and not based on other knowledge), it sounds like you have to make it to that stage to get in.
 
  • #10
Miao said:
For SMALL, do you always have to make it to the shortlist to get in? Or is it specific to some groups like the Number Theory one.

Im not 100% but i think that you do have to make it on the shortlist first.
 
  • #11
West Georgia is still making decisions it seems. Any update on the others?
 
  • #12
WhatIsCohomology said:
Im not 100% but i think that you do have to make it on the shortlist first.
Even for the Geometry project? I have never heard of anyone mentioning the geom shortlist before.
 
  • #13
Miao said:
Even for the Geometry project? I have never heard of anyone mentioning the geom shortlist before.
That was my (unfounded) impression, but like I said, I'm not certain.
 
  • #14
How do you guys prioritize
  • prestige of the program
  • likelihood of publication
  • how interesting the topic is to you
  • location/the "fun" factor
 
  • #15
Should be sending decisions this week: UCSB, DIMACS, WADE
Not for a while: Kansas, Seattle U

Updates on SMALL?
 
  • #16
@test123321 I think it depends on your situation. For me it would be my first time doing original research, so even though I'm only considering places with topics that interest me I would go somewhere that I feel would help me learn and grow more over somewhere that might have a slightly more interesting topic. It's definitely difficult to come up with a definitive way to rank programs given all of the factors, and I think it depends greatly on what you think will help you grow most as well as on your personal preferences (ex: working on your own versus with others).

@alex89029 did/does UCSB do shortlist notifications or anything like that, or will decisions this week be the first piece of info coming from them?
 
  • #17
@cubsin5 I don't think they do shortlists
 
  • Like
Likes WhatIsCohomology
  • #18
Anyone know anything about SUNY or TAMU?UT Tyler and SHSU should both notify around the second or third week of March.
 
  • #19
Since Emory currently has 12 participants listed on their site (and they estimate 10-14), is it safe to say they're done with acceptances?
 
  • #20
alex89O29 said:
Since Emory currently has 12 participants listed on their site (and they estimate 10-14), is it safe to say they're done with acceptances?
That would be my guess.

@WhatIsCohomology I haven't heard anything from Potsdam or TAMU as of yet.
 
  • Like
Likes WhatIsCohomology
  • #21
I got into Cornell with no funding (they only give fundings for Cornell students). Is it worth going when I have a much less prestigious program but with fundings? Btw, I'm a sophomore, so I have one more chance.
 
  • #22
This is my first semester applying to math REUs (current sophomore). I received an acceptance from UCSB yesterday morning - does anyone know how good of a program it is? I'm just curious... I haven't heard from anyone else yet.
 
  • Like
Likes WhatIsCohomology
  • #23
TRetz said:
This is my first semester applying to math REUs (current sophomore). I received an acceptance from UCSB yesterday morning - does anyone know how good of a program it is? I'm just curious... I haven't heard from anyone else yet.

I don't have personal experience with the program, but judging by their list of publications and projects, and some threads I've read on here, it seems like a quite good program. Someone with personal experience can probably speak more to that, though.
 
  • Like
Likes TRetz
  • #24
Anyone know anything about Cornell REU? I got into the PDE one.
 
  • #25
I'm in a similar boat as you, Miao. I'm a soph that got into Cornell's prog. but am a bit iffy on saying if I'll go for sure. I'm in the analysis on fractals group if I do go. I heard from a friend that it was a great program and she really enjoyed it, though I do not have a very detailed comparison or even description.
 
  • #26
n-dimen said:
I'm in a similar boat as you, Miao. I'm a soph that got into Cornell's prog. but am a bit iffy on saying if I'll go for sure. I'm in the analysis on fractals group if I do go. I heard from a friend that it was a great program and she really enjoyed it, though I do not have a very detailed comparison or even description.
Cool! I suppose you are also waiting for other programs. My main problem is I don't know how selective the program is. It used to be very selective, but that might change since they don't offer fundings any more. Thus, it is hard to decide whether it is worth self-funding or not. Anyway, hope we both figure out. We might even see each other this summer!
 
  • #27
Miao said:
Cool! I suppose you are also waiting for other programs. My main problem is I don't know how selective the program is. It used to be very selective, but that might change since they don't offer fundings any more. Thus, it is hard to decide whether it is worth self-funding or not. Anyway, hope we both figure out. We might even see each other this summer!

I did the Cornell program last summer, and I can answer any questions about it.

When they cut the funding last year, there were fewer applicants but it was still selective overall. All but 3 students out of around 30 came from Top 10 math schools (or Cornell which is rank 13), so I'd say it's still pretty prestigious.
 
  • Like
Likes Miao
  • #28
@ everyone who got accepted to a program, I recommend you email program for an update on your status before making a decision.
 
  • #29
Dinstruction said:
I did the Cornell program last summer, and I can answer any questions about it.

When they cut the funding last year, there were fewer applicants but it was still selective overall. All but 3 students out of around 30 came from Top 10 math schools (or Cornell which is rank 13), so I'd say it's still pretty prestigious.
Thank you very much for addressing my concern. I hope to know generally about the project and prospect for publication. Have you heard anything about the Heat equation program by Professor Xiaodong Cao. Also, a rough cost estimate would also be appreciated. Thanks.
 
  • #30
Miao said:
Thank you very much for addressing my concern. I hope to know generally about the project and prospect for publication. Have you heard anything about the Heat equation program by Professor Xiaodong Cao. Also, a rough cost estimate would also be appreciated. Thanks.
I don't know anything about the PDE project. I worked on the fractals project with Professor Strichartz.

I flew in from the west coast, so airfare was somewhere around $500. I stayed at a co-op housing which cost $680 for the whole 8 weeks, plus a $100 security deposit I got back after I left. Add a couple hundred dollars for groceries and other expenses. I was able to get partial reimbursement from my home university after explaining my situation, so you should look into that too.
 
  • Like
Likes Miao
  • #31
Ok so, Twin Cities released first round, Potsdam is releasing first round in the next 2 days, Chicago released, and ICERM did not release yet but has a shortlist you can email asking if you are on it I suppose.
 
  • Like
Likes HBubble and WhatIsCohomology
  • #32
Has anyone heard from MSRI - UP ?
 
  • #33
n-dimen said:
Ok so, Twin Cities released first round, Potsdam is releasing first round in the next 2 days, Chicago released, and ICERM did not release yet but has a shortlist you can email asking if you are on it I suppose.
You got into all of them? Or they told you so?
 
  • Like
Likes WhatIsCohomology
  • #34
tesselate said:
Has anyone heard from MSRI - UP ?
I know someone who has
 
  • #35
Had anyone heard back from Oregon state?
 
  • #36
Any update on Ipam RIPS, UCLA?
 
  • #37
Any word from Michigan yet?
 
  • #38
I emailed the programs since I have offers and I want other kids to know if they got in ASAP for a program I may not want, so I emailed the programs.

More info:
Seattle will give decisions in two weeks.
Oregon State will release before the 8th.
UT Tyler emailed first acceptances today.
Cornell emailed formal first round acceptances today.
Grand Valley State will email first acceptances 3/2 and 3/3 most likely.
UCSB emailed the top 4 students for my chosen project but had a shortlist of 9 people, the 4 kids have until 3/8 to reply.
 
  • Like
Likes TRetz, WhatIsCohomology and HBubble
  • #39
I'm only waiting for Michigan. That's literally the only thing preventing me from accepting Cornell.
 
  • #40
@n-dimen Thanks! That really helps a lot. I'm surprised UT Tyler is sending out responses so early after the deadline. Makes me think I should have applied earlier.
 
  • #41
Chicago released results.
 
  • #42
n-dimen said:
UCSB emailed the top 4 students for my chosen project but had a shortlist of 9 people, the 4 kids have until 3/8 to reply.

What project? I applied to the braided linear algebra one and got in
 
  • #43
Still no word from TAMU, either?
 
  • #44
TRetz said:
What project? I applied to the braided linear algebra one and got in
That may have been it, I do not recall which project I picked. TAMU sent first round offers (I didnt make it either...).
 
  • Like
Likes WhatIsCohomology
  • #45
n-dimen said:
That may have been it, I do not recall which project I picked. TAMU sent first round offers (I didnt make it either...).

Thanks! Man, this sure is encouraging so far.
 
  • #46
Refreshing my email nonstop... was hoping to hear from someplace I had an interview but I guess this is a bad sign :(
 
  • #47
It seems that REU's are very competitive regardless of prestige.
 
  • Like
Likes n-dimen and TRetz
  • #48
I heard back from RIPS. People are supposed to respond by the morning of March 7th so I imagine they'll send out second offers after that
 
  • #49
  • #50
@test123321 via phone and then via email when I didn't pick up the first two days
 

Similar threads

Replies
30
Views
9K
Replies
77
Views
19K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
29
Views
14K
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
64
Views
12K
Back
Top