What Are the Unique Properties of Water and How Do They Affect Its Behavior?

  • Thread starter Thread starter neginf
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Water
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the nature of water molecules and their arrangement. It questions whether adjacent water molecules fit together tightly enough to be considered "continuous," suggesting that the answer is likely "no" due to the presence of gaps between them. This leads to the idea that many materials, including water, are predominantly empty space. The conversation also explores the appearance of a calm water surface at a microscopic level, proposing that if magnified sufficiently, the surface would reveal a more irregular and dynamic structure rather than a smooth one. Participants emphasize that everything in the universe, except for extreme cases like black holes and neutron stars, consists mostly of space, which challenges the perception of solidity in everyday objects. The discussion highlights the limitations of visual representations of molecular structures, noting that they often oversimplify the complex behaviors of molecules and their interactions.
neginf
Messages
56
Reaction score
0
1. Do adjacent water molecules fit together so tightly that water is "continuous" ?
2. If the answer to 1. is "no", what is in between them ?
3. What would the surface of a calm puddle look like if magnifed so individual molecules could be seen?
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
what does "continuous" mean to you in this context? Molecules are almost nothing but pure emptiness, so what is it that would be "continuous".
 
Maybe I should have asked if it had no gaps instead of using the word "continuous".

Is the answer to 1. "no" because the molecules are mostly gaps to start with and have gaps between them ?
Does this mean many things in ordinary life are mostly empty space ?

Does the surface of calm water appear smooth because of scale - if you could magnify it enough to see individual molecules, would that surface actually be not smooth and even changing shape ?
 
neginf said:
Maybe I should have asked if it had no gaps instead of using the word "continuous".

Is the answer to 1. "no" because the molecules are mostly gaps to start with and have gaps between them ?
Does this mean many things in ordinary life are mostly empty space ?

Does the surface of calm water appear smooth because of scale - if you could magnify it enough to see individual molecules, would that surface actually be not smooth and even changing shape ?

Water's a lot smoother than many things but I'm sure if you could see down to enough granularity it would be very ragged.

It's not that "many thing in ordinary life are mostly empty space" it's that EVERYTHING (outside of black holes and neutron stars) is amost pure space.
 
Thank you very much.
 
For number three it would look something like this, the molecules at the top represent evaporation.

A5040064-Molecular_structure_of_water_vapour-SPL.jpg
 
Nice picture, but it shows molecules as solid objects. This is not entirely correct - in some situations they behave like that, in others they don't.
 
I would agree with your comment Borek but to visualize what's happening we could never illustrate it with enough detail to include electrons in their orbitals and such.

Also it was one of the better images on google and I couldn't find anything clearer.
 
Back
Top