What Connects Mass, Energy, and Time Translations?

  • Thread starter Thread starter canopus
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Mass
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the fundamental questions of why mass and energy exist, with participants expressing uncertainty about their origins. It highlights that while mass can be viewed as a condensed form of energy, the deeper question of what composes mass remains unanswered. The Higgs field is mentioned as a potential explanation for particle mass, but the nature of this field itself is questioned. Participants suggest that inquiries about existence may lean more towards philosophy than physics, emphasizing the complexity of these concepts. Ultimately, the conversation reflects the ongoing struggle to understand the foundational aspects of mass, energy, and their relationship to time and space.
canopus
Why do we have mass? How can we explain it?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Scientist are unable to explain why mass is here.
 
E = mc^2 Mass is energy.
 
He is not asking that.
 
I see him asking this: What composes mass? The relation between mass and energy is not valid to answer that question. Mass is a condensed form of energy and not a composition of mass.
 
It would be she (;

Why do we have energy then? I can explain why we have volume, but when it comes to mass or energy, i can't find a word to say.
 
canopus said:
Why do we have mass?
canopus said:
Why do we have energy then?
In order to better understand your question, are you taking anything for granted? For example, are you also asking why we have time and space, and why we have the universe? By the way, I am not sure that I understand what you mean by "we have" rather than something such as "there exists".

I can explain why we have volume
If you explain why you think that "we have" volume, then prehaps we others will better understand the perspective behind your question.
 
As i undrestood, in physics, we can't ask ''why'', we can just ask ''how''... According to your sentences, i suspected what i know!
 
Why do we have volume?
 
  • #10
I think questions like these belong on the philosophy forum.
 
  • #11
Nenad said:
I think questions like these belong on the philosophy forum.
In my opinion this is the correct forum for these questions. E.g. I believe particle physicists are now saying that there is something called a Higgs field which is responsible for the mass of particles. As far as why we have volume, well that's a legitimate and involved question which includes the topic of space and that's something Einstein touches on in one of his relativity books.

Pete
 
  • #12
pmb_phy said:
In my opinion this is the correct forum for these questions. E.g. I believe particle physicists are now saying that there is something called a Higgs field which is responsible for the mass of particles. As far as why we have volume, well that's a legitimate and involved question which includes the topic of space and that's something Einstein touches on in one of his relativity books.

Pete

and what is responsibe for this higgs field?
 
  • #13
pmb_phy said:
...As far as why we have volume, well that's a legitimate and involved question which includes the topic of space and that's something Einstein touches on in one of his relativity books.

Pete

I am rather wondering how canopus explains volume. Personnally, I do find the question philosophically inclined.
 
  • #14
canopus said:
Why do we have energy then?
Because we aren't invariant under time translations.
 
Back
Top