Actually, "evaporation temperature," on its own, doesn't really mean anything, so I was being imprecise in my answer above. All materials evaporate at a non-zero rate above 0K. Are we talking about the boiling temperature? Or perhaps we're talking about a temperature where the partial pressure is a certain amount, e.g., 10 kPa. In any case, we should be a little more specific.
If A, B, and C are totally immiscible (that is, the heat or enthalpy of mixing is zero, with oil and water being a good example), then the evaporation processes will be uncoupled, and A, then B, then C will leave the mixture (assuming they are all present on the surface). However, the situation will be different if they form a compound, for example.
In your thought experiment, the cylinder with the larger surface area will be more efficient in evaporation at a given temperature. If the heating process if fast compared to the evaporation time, then the same power is required in each case (because the volume of liquid is equal). However, if the heating process is slow (that is, significant evaporation occurs as the temperature increases to its final value), then the cylinder with the larger surface area will require less power.