What is topic number 9 on eurekalert.org and why is it important?

  • Thread starter Thread starter tgin_polish
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Gravity
AI Thread Summary
Gravity is a complex topic that intertwines general relativity and quantum mechanics, both of which are well-established yet incompatible theories. General relativity describes gravity as the curvature of space-time, while quantum mechanics deals with the fundamental forces at a microscopic level. The challenge arises when attempting to unify these theories, as naive quantum gravity leads to nonsensical results. String theory is one proposed solution, suggesting that fundamental particles are not point-like but rather one-dimensional strings, which could reconcile these discrepancies. Understanding gravity at this level requires substantial background knowledge and self-study, as the concepts are still evolving and not fully resolved.
tgin_polish
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Gravity - Do you know it?

I am required by my physics class to write a report concerning topic number 9 on the following site
http://www.eurekalert.org/features/doe/2002-02/ddoe-1pq061502.php

I am having a great deal a difficulty even starting to write on the topic. I am not what you would classify a bright physics student. Any incite into this topic would be greatly appreciated.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Google search for quantum gravity.

Warning: An indepth explanation is *hard* and not understood even by the best physicists in the world. I recommend you pick up Brian Greene's book the elegant universe, and Lee Smolins 3 roads to quantum gravity. They are written for the Layman, so it should be approachable especially if you have some undergrad level of understanding of quantum mechanics and special relativity.
 
C'mon fellas. I know there are some smart people on these boards. I need to write 10 pages on this topic. For the love of God please help me.
 
I don't know if I'm smart or not, but I do know a little something about what you're asking =)

And I'm telling you, get those books and do a little self research, b/c the answers you're looking for are not found in a paragraph on an internet forum.

Why don't you ask a very specific question, b/c frankly its akin to asking someone 'what's the history of Europe like, someone has got to know a little something?'

But here's a paragraph all the same.

General relativity is Einstein's theory of gravitation. It involves the geometrization of space and time and making that the primary source term for generating gravity, its a very large scale force. Quantum mechanics + special relativity, is the study of the very small (the remaining 3 forces in nature). Both theories are well tested experimentally in their own domains of validity. Mathematically however, they don't mix well. In part b/c GR involves compact, more or less continuous geometry, and quantum mechanics discrete 'fuzziness' and potentially nonlocal effects. When you mix them in a naive quantum version of gravity, you get a theory that involves gravitons that output pathological infinities (read nonsense). In a sense, the theory breaks down. So we expect something 'new' to emerge, in much the same way that Fermi theory of weak decay broke down and led to modern Electroweak theory.

String theory is one attempt to get past the problem, essentialy removing the point particle as a fundamental unit, and instead postulating a 1dimensional or larger 'brane' to replace it. Geometry in string theory, then is an emergent 'field' just like all others, and not truly fundamental. Particles and forces are interpreted as excitations of various 'string' modes of oscillation.

Please understand, that at the level I am talking at, these things are very unprecise and in many ways WRONG. But that's the way things are, in a field that as yet is still work in progress.
 
Thank you much Haelfix.
 
So I know that electrons are fundamental, there's no 'material' that makes them up, it's like talking about a colour itself rather than a car or a flower. Now protons and neutrons and quarks and whatever other stuff is there fundamentally, I want someone to kind of teach me these, I have a lot of questions that books might not give the answer in the way I understand. Thanks
Back
Top