Which B.S. degree is more employable: finance or statistics?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the employability of two Bachelor of Science degrees: finance and statistics, particularly with a business emphasis. Participants explore various factors influencing job prospects, personal interests, and the evolving job market over the duration of a degree program.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Exploratory

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants argue that the employability of a degree can change significantly over time, suggesting that personal interest and engagement in the subject matter may lead to better job prospects.
  • There is a viewpoint that finance graduates often enter low-paying analyst roles or high-risk sales positions, which depend heavily on sales skills.
  • Others express skepticism about the idea of following one's passion, citing examples of graduates in less lucrative fields, such as art.
  • One participant suggests that if employment is the primary concern, pursuing a trade might be a more viable option than completing a degree.
  • Another perspective is that for roles like management analyst, the specific degree may be less important than skills such as internship experience, communication, and quantitative abilities.
  • A participant advocates for a degree in statistics, arguing it may provide broader opportunities in quantitative analysis and eligibility for further studies.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of opinions, with no clear consensus on which degree is more employable. Some emphasize the importance of personal interest, while others focus on job market realities and specific skills required for desired positions.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight the uncertainty of job markets and the potential for significant changes over the course of a degree program. There is also mention of the importance of personal engagement in studies and the varying definitions of employability.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals considering a degree in finance or statistics, those interested in career prospects in business-related fields, and students weighing their options based on personal interests and job market trends.

annoyinggirl
Messages
217
Reaction score
10
Which B.S degree is more employable : finance or statistics (Business emphasis)?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Generally speaking, questions of this sort are ill posed.

Don't forget that you will be in the degree program for 4 years. The situation will change quite a bit by the time you finish. Possibly drastically. Consider what the situation would have been like if you had entered the degree in the fall of 2007. By the time you finished the degree the economy is suddenly thrashed.

On the other side, you should be thinking about what you will enjoy more. What will cause you to want to leap out of bed in the morning and rush to class? What will be sufficiently interesting to you in order to cause you to be eager to do the work required to finish the degree? What holds your attention enough that you miss your stop on the bus because you are reading about it?

Being willing to do the work, being interested in the subject, this will cause you to finish higher in your class. This will get you better letters of recommendation. This will cause you to actually pay attention in class. And somebody who knows his subject is more employable than somebody who is just sort of dragging-through in something that is theoretically "higher prestige." Give me a keener in any even vaguely related subject every time. Let the guy who is just passively moving forward get hired by the other company.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: epenguin
Agree with DEvens.

Typical finance BS graduates go on to either lowish paying analyst jobs with little upside potential, or challenging sales jobs with high upsides and high downsides. I would only go that route if you're interested in selling financial instruments. (Many of those sales jobs have titles like "advisor" or "consultant", but your success ultimately depends on your ability to sell)
 
Locrian said:
Agree with DEvens.

Typical finance BS graduates go on to either lowish paying analyst jobs with little upside potential, or challenging sales jobs with high upsides and high downsides. I would only go that route if you're interested in selling financial instruments. (Many of those sales jobs have titles like "advisor" or "consultant", but your success ultimately depends on your ability to sell)
what about BS statistics graduates?
 
DEvens said:
Generally speaking, questions of this sort are ill posed.

Don't forget that you will be in the degree program for 4 years. The situation will change quite a bit by the time you finish. Possibly drastically. Consider what the situation would have been like if you had entered the degree in the fall of 2007. By the time you finished the degree the economy is suddenly thrashed.

On the other side, you should be thinking about what you will enjoy more. What will cause you to want to leap out of bed in the morning and rush to class? What will be sufficiently interesting to you in order to cause you to be eager to do the work required to finish the degree? What holds your attention enough that you miss your stop on the bus because you are reading about it?

Being willing to do the work, being interested in the subject, this will cause you to finish higher in your class. This will get you better letters of recommendation. This will cause you to actually pay attention in class. And somebody who knows his subject is more employable than somebody who is just sort of dragging-through in something that is theoretically "higher prestige." Give me a keener in any even vaguely related subject every time. Let the guy who is just passively moving forward get hired by the other company.
thanks for commenting, and i know you mean well, but i never got that "follow your heart and the money will follow" thing. I mean, think about art majors and their fate post graduation.

i don't really have passion for anything. I guess if i had to choose, it would be like industrial engineering, which at this point, i cannot do. My school also doesn't offer it.

Something that would make me leap out of my bed is the thought of gainful employment and great employment prospects
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: math_denial
annoyinggirl said:
thanks for commenting, and i know you mean well, but i never got that "follow your heart and the money will follow" thing. I mean, think about art majors and their fate post graduation.

i don't really have passion for anything. I guess if i had to choose, it would be like industrial engineering, which at this point, i cannot do. My school also doesn't offer it.

Something that would make me leap out of my bed is the thought of gainful employment and great employment prospects

If the only thing that you care about is gainful employment, then you could just as easily drop out of university and take up a trade (e.g. electrician, X-ray or MRI technician) since these are in very high demand. Or if you're willing to spend more years in school, you could pursue a degree in medicine or pharmacy.

Ultimately, what you would want is a field that you are at least interested in and which has good employment prospects. In which case, you might as well continue with your statistics degree, as I've posted in the other thread.
 
StatGuy2000 said:
If the only thing that you care about is gainful employment, then you could just as easily drop out of university and take up a trade (e.g. electrician, X-ray or MRI technician) since these are in very high demand. Or if you're willing to spend more years in school, you could pursue a degree in medicine or pharmacy.

Ultimately, what you would want is a field that you are at least interested in and which has good employment prospects. In which case, you might as well continue with your statistics degree, as I've posted in the other thread.
i'm equally interested in both finance and statistics. I am interested in the business side of statistics and the business side of finance. My dream job would be something like management analyst. would finance or statistics B.S be better for jobs like this?
 
annoyinggirl said:
i'm equally interested in both finance and statistics. I am interested in the business side of statistics and the business side of finance. My dream job would be something like management analyst. would finance or statistics B.S be better for jobs like this?

If your dream job would be something like a management analyst, then it really wouldn't matter that much whether you have a BS in finance or statistics. Positions like these depend far more on the following:

(1) having internship experience,
(2) great communication skills, and
(3) demonstrated quantitative skills.

A BS in statistics will certainly give you (3) and you should be seeking out (1) while you are in school. My personal opinion is that a BS in statistics is more worthwhile than a BS in finance for the simple reason that a BS in statistics will open up more opportunities in positions that require quantitative analyses, as well as qualify you for graduate studies in statistics, should you decide to take that route (I strongly encourage you to pursue at least a MS in statistics or a related field like operations research, which you can pursue with a BS in statistics, since that would offer you the widest possible opportunities available).
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
5K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
26K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
7K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
6K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K