Why Does My Statics Solution Differ from the Textbook's Answer?

  • Thread starter Thread starter physstudent1
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Mechanics Statics
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on a physics problem involving the calculation of the resultant force and its location on an I beam subjected to two forces and a couple. The user calculated the resultant force to be 4kN downward at 6m, while the textbook states it should be at 5m. Clarification is sought on the method of moving forces to a specific point to simplify calculations. A response emphasizes the importance of summing moments correctly to determine the resultant's location, suggesting that the couple affects the moment calculations. Accurate moment summation is crucial for resolving discrepancies between the user's solution and the textbook answer.
physstudent1
Messages
267
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement



Determine and locate the resultant R of the two forces and one couple acting on the I beam.

---x

====|====O====|

I understand this is kind of hard to understand this is the best I could do "====" = 3 ft
first | = 6kN force upwards
O= couple 52kN m ccw
second | = 10kN downards

Homework Equations


The Attempt at a Solution



I chose to move all the forces to b where the couple was so that I wouldn't have to wry about the force caused by said couple when finding the resultant. The resultant would then be 4kN down at 6m. However the book says the answer is 4kN down at 5m I am really confused can somebody please help me if you need more help to understand the question please ask.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
physstudent1 said:

Homework Statement



Determine and locate the resultant R of the two forces and one couple acting on the I beam.

---x

====|====O====|

I understand this is kind of hard to understand this is the best I could do "====" = 3 ft
first | = 6kN force upwards
O= couple 52kN m ccw
second | = 10kN downards

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



I chose to move all the forces to b where the couple was so that I wouldn't have to wry about the force caused by said couple when finding the resultant. The resultant would then be 4kN down at 6m. However the book says the answer is 4kN down at 5m I am really confused can somebody please help me if you need more help to understand the question please ask.
You did a good job explaining the problem. But I am not sure what you mean by moving the forces to b. The resultant force must be 4kN down as you noted, but you must correctly determining its location by first summing moments about any point, including the couple, (which just adds or subtracts from the moments of the forces), then solve for the distance the 4kN resultant must be from that point in order to get the same summed moments.
 
Thread 'Have I solved this structural engineering equation correctly?'
Hi all, I have a structural engineering book from 1979. I am trying to follow it as best as I can. I have come to a formula that calculates the rotations in radians at the rigid joint that requires an iterative procedure. This equation comes in the form of: $$ x_i = \frac {Q_ih_i + Q_{i+1}h_{i+1}}{4K} + \frac {C}{K}x_{i-1} + \frac {C}{K}x_{i+1} $$ Where: ## Q ## is the horizontal storey shear ## h ## is the storey height ## K = (6G_i + C_i + C_{i+1}) ## ## G = \frac {I_g}{h} ## ## C...
Back
Top