Why Doesn't an Object Submerged in Water Always Sink?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bengo
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Force
AI Thread Summary
An object submerged in water does not always sink because the forces acting on it, specifically buoyant force and weight, determine its motion. If the buoyant force is less than the object's weight, it will accelerate downward, but other forces, like being held or suspended, can prevent this. An object can remain at a constant depth if it has neutral buoyancy, meaning its density matches that of the water. Additionally, if an object is initially moving downward, it may continue to sink until reaching terminal velocity. Understanding these principles clarifies why submerged objects can exhibit different behaviors in water.
Bengo
Messages
46
Reaction score
0
Can someone please help me understand this conceptually? If there is an object completely submerged in say water and if there is an apparent weight I don't understand why that object wouldn't accelerate downward. In the air an object can reach terminal velocity and move an constant velocity but I don't understand how the object in water can just stay still. Does that make sense? Thanks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
In air, an object can also stand still. Balloons do. Same principle.
 
In a few of my questions they talk about apparent weight in water (when the object is completely submerged) where the buoyant force is smaller than the weight of the object, my question is why doesn't the object accelerate downward in the water. I understand that when the object is partially submerged the weight equals the buoyant force so the net force is zero and the object has no acceleration. But i get confused when it is entirely submerged. If someone could explain to me what I'm missing here I would appreciate it.
 
Bengo said:
In a few of my questions they talk about apparent weight in water (when the object is completely submerged) where the buoyant force is smaller than the weight of the object, my question is why doesn't the object accelerate downward in the water. I understand that when the object is partially submerged the weight equals the buoyant force so the net force is zero and the object has no acceleration. But i get confused when it is entirely submerged. If someone could explain to me what I'm missing here I would appreciate it.
I don't think you're missing anything. If the buoyant force is smaller than the weight, and those are the only forces acting, then the object will accelerate downward. But often the object is suspended (by a rope, say) or held up in some manner, so other forces act.
 
Bengo said:
But i get confused when it is entirely submerged.

Just the fact that an object is submerged does not mean that its buoyant force is smaller than its weight. It could have been made submerged by some other force that has since been removed. The motion will depend on the CURRENT forces.
 
Submarines are good at staying completely submerged without accelerating downward.

In all floating bodies, including some submerged ones, the weight (W) of the body is balanced by the buoyant force (B). Since Sum F = B - W = 0 = ma, then the body undergoes no motion in the vertical direction.

If, on the other hand, the body is not floating, this implies that the weight is greater than the buoyancy. In this case,
Sum F = B-W = ma, but Sum F < 0,
and the body will sink, accelerating until it reaches some terminal velocity (provided the water is deep enough to permit this).
 
Thank you so much everyone. So is it correct to say the only way an object will stay submerged in a liquid and not sink to the bottom is if it has the same density as the liquid?
 
Even in this case it might sink - if its initial velocity is downward. If the velocity has no vertical component, then it will stay at some constant depth.
 
Bengo said:
So is it correct to say the only way an object will stay submerged in a liquid and not sink to the bottom is if it has the same density as the liquid?
Yes. See: Neutral buoyancy
 
Back
Top